Senate Standing Committee on Agriculture and Environment
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Calling to order the Joint Committee on Public Safety, Military affairs and Ways and Means. We'll hear from the Department of Corrections who will present their biennium budget requests.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Good afternoon. Thank you. Good afternoon. Chair Dela Cruz, Vice Chair Elephante and Members of the Committee. As you know, I'm Tommy Johnson, the Director of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. So I'd like to first introduce some of my team that's here, my leadership team. We have our Deputy Director for Administration, Melanie Martin.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Our Deputy Director for Correctional Institutions, Pamela Sturch. But she's in the office. She just returned back from Arizona yesterday. We have our Deputy Director for Rehabilitation Services and Programs, Solomon Uno. We have the Executive Director for cbcc, Pamela Ferguson Bray. And from the Hawaii Polling Authority we have the Administrator Corey Reinke here.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
As well as representatives from DAGS as the expendit agency on some of our projects. I have six pages of testimony. With the Committee's permission, I would just like to summarize. Yeah, then we can get into the Committee would encourage. So real quick. We have four short term goals, as you can see on page one. Reduce overcrowding.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Improve your living and working conditions. The living conditions for those in our custody and care and our staff working in the facilities. Fill our vacancies. And we have a good stride in filling our correctional officer vacancies. But we still have some work to do. Expand our mental health services statewide. And update our correctional master plan.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
As you know, the last Update was in 2003. Our long term goals are to relocate the Kauai Community Correctional Facility. We have some funding for that plan. And build a new jail in West Oahu in Kona. Over 30% of the folks in our Hilo jail are from the Kona side.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Plan to relocate the Maui Community Correctional center and plan to relocate to Hawaii Community Correctional Center. And also to try to bring back the thousand plus inmates we have on the mainland. Excuse me, not a thousand. I think I have it here. We have 938 on the mainland now. That's due to a temporary surge.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
We closed down two housing units at Halawa to do major repairs to electrical. And so 240 of that 938 we'll be coming back. Once we get the repairs done in the two modules at Halawa Correctional Facility. We still struggle with staffing shortages.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
But we've been able to reduce through an aggressive multi pronged approach on our recruitment, we've been able to reduce our ACO vacancy rate from 30.4% to 24%. That includes emergency hires. We will continue that we increased our recruitment efforts in a number of ways.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
But basically we in 2023 we put 56 officers on the floor with three classes. ACO recruit classes. We held six classes in 2024 and we put 136 on the floor. And we plan to hold six classes in 202526 and on to try to get ahead of the silver tsunami of the retirements and the normal attrition rate.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
As you know, our jails are severely overcrowded, in particular OCCC and ACCC. We recently opened a 48 bed unit at ACCC which will release some of the overcrowding but not enough. And we recently completed major projects at the Oahu Community Correctional Center. Risk Effective Population Management.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
I only control about 5% of the population in our custody and care. We have to take everybody sent to us. So regardless of our census, if the court sentenced someone to us, HPA returns somebody to custody of the court to issue a bench warrant and places a probation violated in custody, we have to take them.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
That's why our jails are overcrowded. That and the fact that we have our sentence misdemeanance and pretrial are spending an inordinate amount of time, particularly pretrial population incarcerated without being released. Seven out of the 10 requests we submit to the courts for supervisor release are denied.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
So we're trying to ramp up our electronic monitoring and hopefully the courts will approve some of those for release. But that's an indication that 87% of our pretrial population and sentenced misdemeanor population, excuse me, the pre trial and misdemeanor population here in the state is 87% when you compare to our sentence felon population.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
So what that tells us is we have people in our custody who probably should be on supervised release in the community who had better be served. And we're spending approximately $307 a day to keep people in custody who may have a $50 bail.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
We also have people in our custody who clearly have mental health issues who if it weren't for their mental health illness, probably would not be involved in the criminal justice system. And the jails are the worst place for these folks because it's the least effective, most costly.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
There needs to be some type of intermediate place for them to be in the community where they can receive the services, housing and the help they need instead of coming to jail, which again is $307 a day. With respect to our non General funds.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
There's a link on page five where you can go and see that Our budget requests listed there. We had some other requests. We would like to highlight that the biggest request in our budget is the $30 million to complete the planning and design and the bridging documents, rfp, RFQ and the bridging documents for the new CCCC project.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
I am aware that the Commission, the oversight Commission, sent a letter to the legislators and the Governor to halt the planning and design. But I believe we can do both. We can improve the system and continue with the planning and design. O Triple C is old and obsolete. It's manpower intensive.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
To give you an example, there's 413 correctional officer positions there. If we build a new, more modern facility, we can not only meet the needs of the offenders we have today, but we can probably do that for about less than 300 corrections officers and build a facility that can hold about 1300.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Right now, OCCC is design capacity of 628. We routinely have over 900 folks there today. As of today, we have 947 people at O Triple C with a design capacity of 628. So we're severely overcrowded and has been that way for decades. With that said, that is a summarize of our testimony.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Okay, I went too far. Hold on. Sorry. Okay, so these are our asks. I can go right down the list. Okay, so the $4 million ask is to add to our reentry services. You'll see the Commission report on the State of reentry in Hawaii. It's a damning report and it should be. We do have challenges.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
There are a lot of things we're unable to do because we simply don't have the funding to do the wraparound reentry services. This $4 million we're for in the budget allows us to do some of those reentry services to include providing housing when they first get out for.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
For a small period of time to provide case management services in the community. So the warm handoff and linkage to provide other services in the community that can better serve the needs of the person instead of being incarcerated, that we think will help us reduce recidivism. By doing that, we will be able to have safer communities.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
So we plan to split that $4 million up into several different initiatives so that we can come back and show proof of concept to the Legislature so you'll see that the not wasted and hopefully at some point increase that funding where we can show you that what we're doing is successful. It's not going to be easy.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
We're going to have hiccups, but we're going to try the $100,000 there is to provide assistance with successful reintegration for that. That's strictly the documents for it to provide. We haven't. We finally have the Social Security Administration signed off on an MOU with us to provide replacement Social Security cards for American born citizens.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
We already have a process in place to help a person obtain a separate. Excuse me, a replacement birth certificate. We have a process in place. We need to increase to have a person get a civil ID card while they're in our custody.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
One of the other initiatives we want to look at is if a person is in our custody and they have a driver's license, try to get that driver's license renewed before it expires. Before they get out. Once it expires, they have to go through the testing again. You have the $210,000 there for the refuge collection.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
That's just an increase in the cost to operate. We have $400,000 increased coverage for security surveillance systems. You'll see $125 for $125,000 for the fire alarm system, which we need to have for sure. $180,000 in additional for security radios and equipment. Some of our radios are 15 to 20 years old.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
$146,794 to replace in cell toilet sink modules. That's where the sink and the toilet is. Just one unit together. And then the Last 1 is $112,000 for technician level trauma informed care for non uniform staff. That is table six Members.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Thank you, Director Johnson. Happy new year. April 15th. Your CIP request. So this is for the new OCCC, the $30 million? Yeah. So that's. You don't have a request in fiscal year 27. It's just fiscal year 26.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Right. So I'll explain why we did that. The. We originally had a request in for $250 million for fiscal year 27. And speaking with the governor's office, we decided to push that to fiscal year 2028 because of several reasons. One, the animal quarantine facility, the DLNR needs to. Department of Agriculture needs to move out of that facility.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
And part of the $250 million ask in 2020 is the demolition of that facility so that we can bring in the heavy equipment to start the construction. If we get the funding that we.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Ask for the 30 million requests. Thank you for that. Does that also include design for new courtrooms to make it more efficient?
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Yes. So inside of each new facility we put up, we have decided. I've already spoken to Rod Miley and Chief. Chief Justice Reckonwald is speaking to the chief district judge and the chief circuit court judge to determine whether one courtroom inside the jail or two will do.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
We agreed that we would put whatever they needed in the facility, including have it hooked up electronically to do the court, to do the hearings, distance hearings. Also that we would. That we would support their request for staffing the courts.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
It's important to have the courtrooms in the jails to cut down on transportation because that's the most dangerous, dangerous time for corrections officers when we're doing transports. If we're able to later on put a new jail in Kona, then it will have a court.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
It will have a courtroom in the jail because we're constantly putting vans on the road for two and a half hours each way. So in the O, triple C. Yes, I've already spoken to them.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
And I'm waiting for Rod Meyer to get back to me so we can sit down with whoever their point of contact is to come out with the layout. How they want the courtroom to be laid out. Now, it's not going to be mahogany and ported glass. It will be bricks and mortar. Court. Thank you. Thank you, chair.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
The 30 is for planning design. Then it's planning design. That'll give you a better cost and construction.
- Tommy Johnson
Person
Right. And the rfq, RFP process and the bridging documents. Any other questions?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Adjourned. Thank you. Zero, my God. Thank you. We'll rec at 2:30. Thanks, Chair. Thanks, Vice Chair. I appreciate it.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
zero, sorry. We have law enforcement D and leave yearly in the DOD and then we have Department of Ag. Okay, well, recess so that we can switch them out.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, finally meeting back to order. So now we hear from the Department of Law Enforcement. Good afternoon. Happy New Year.1
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Good afternoon Chair, Vice Chair, Members of Committee, thank you for the opportunity for let us to talk about our initiatives just quickly to summarize what we're trying to do this coming year.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
It is to implement a agricultural crime enforcement program, to implement a traffic enforcement program which includes a commercial vehicle inspection to solidify our efforts in the fight against illegal fireworks with the development of a explosive enforcement program.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We are also still trying to build a police facility with overnight holding capabilities of detainees at the DKI airport location which is the enterprise lot. It will not only house our cell block but our special operations section and airport patrol section. We are also requesting planning, design and site selection for still for the state training center.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We would also like to build a police facility in central Oahu by Wahiawa area to use that as a staging location for our agricultural crime and traffic enforcement and fireworks program.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And we are also requesting to build a police facility in leeward Oahu to support the same functions and also to use as a staging area to respond to violence out in that area and also to provide coverage for some of the schools.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
At DOE's request, we are looking to invest in next gen law enforcement Internet technology that would help us with our staffing needs but also with these IT enhancements it will help us in our investigations statewide.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We are and finally we are still trying to reduce the salary disparity between the state law enforcement officers and our county counterparts so that we can fill our vacancy shortage. And we are available for questions maybe. We go over like in Table 6.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So those were the. Approved by the Governor. The yellow. Okay, that's fine, you can go.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So just, just now why don't before you start just state the Department wide priority so we know which line. Okay, so if it skips around that's okay because of what you just said. Let's just state the number and we can track it. zero you know, before, before you start though you want to.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I'm sorry. So on. On my right is Brandon Azuka, my Executive officer. To my left is Durazo Fong, my aso. Behind me Jared Radula, the Deputy Director for Law enforcement. Michael Vincent, Deputy Director for Administration. Behind him is Thomas Yamamoto, our fiscal officer and our hr. Thank you.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So in looking, in looking at our priority numbers on table six. Thank you. Priority one through six is actually relates to the salary disparity. But in talking with the governor's office they are going to put a placeholder in the budget once they can resolve the mechanics on how, on. On how to resolve this disparity.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So they are working with the union and working with budget and finance on that. And then we skip down to the next. Our next priority would be the law enforcement IT software project where we are requesting $25 million for FY26 and FY27 and Brandon can go over what we're trying to achieve.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
So two things. First thing is using or replacing some of our vacancies on our administrative side, using IT to hopefully alleviate some of the long term vacancies and costs for personnel. What we've been focused on recently is the travel approval form. We've actually worked close to going live to automate that.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
I know it takes hours and hours to fill out this form. So we've worked on a solution to automate it where you can actually select the the city or where the conference is. And through AI, it'll pull hotels, the cheapest hotels and flights where you can just select and make that process a lot easier.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
We've also looked at our internal HR transactions, how to move people within our organization quicker to make it easier for managers and secretaries to be able to plug in, you know, the 89 days or do the counting for the staff. And then finally we're looking at how to streamline procurement for our Department.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
So those are the kind of the initial administrative functions that we've taken a look at. And as far as law enforcement statewide, we are very interested in creating a statewide personnel and critical infrastructure situational awareness platform where we can protect the state's critical infrastructure interests as well as personnel.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
So I know there's issues with notifications in this building. You know, if something goes on next door, you want to know what's going on. So we're working on a platform where, you know, all appointed officials, all staff will be notified immediately of what's going on in the area.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
And then you'll be provided updates to know what law enforcement is doing or first responders in General to keep people safe. And then also in those critical situations, we're working on an application through the Safer Watch platform that will, I guess, give guidance.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
But we don't want to tell people exactly what to do if there's, you know, an active shooter or a fire, but provide guidance on how to keep yourself or yourself, your staff safe.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
You know, if the incident is occurring on the east side, you know, how can we get personnel on the west side out of that building as soon as possible and then bring first responders in through a different entrance so that they don't cross paths. So overall, how we.
- Brandon Azuka
Person
How we can protect the state's critical infrastructure and then provide notifications and keep state personnel safe. So that's what our IT ask covers.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Okay, moving on to priority number 21 was 16. Yeah, 16 is. Is a. Is a request for three FD positions to manage our grants over at the office of homeland security. Okay. Item number 20, we're. We're anticipating the Wahiawa Civic Civic center and court complex to be up in 18 months.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we're requesting 18 FTEs for deputies not only to cover the courthouse, but the state building that's next to it, the parking complex. And also if available, they will do some regional patrols of the schools in the area. We're asking for them to be funded with a.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Funds that will give us the latitude to have them complete all of those law enforcement functions as opposed to the u funds that was originally made by the. By the governor's Office. Priority number 23 is the prescription monitoring program, Annual maintenance costs, and that's $460,000. I mean, and 810. Excuse me, for FY26 and 27.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And then on priority number 24 is the additional funding needed for the annual operating expenses for narcotics enforcement division. And that was 392,000 for FY26 and 402,000 for FY27. Moving down to item number 30 is the annual maintenance fee for the narcotics enforcement laboratory, which is nationally and internationally certified.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And that cost is 64,000 for FY26 and 74,000 for FY27. You want to.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yeah. And then after this, we have things. That are not on here.
- Durazo Fong
Person
Okay. After this, we have. We have the traffic section that we want to bring in, and then the section. And that one is request for 27 positions. And that's at 5 million. Which priority number. So this is something new that came in after. Because after we gave the report. Other.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay. You know, maybe what we can do is get the. At some point, update the form, and then you can just add the. But why don't you explain it now? Okay. You want to explain the traffic? Sure.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So what happened after the budget submission? Department of Transportation approached us and wanted DLE to increase its presence on the highway for. For speeding, DUI enforcement and commercial vehicles inspection. The commercial vehicles inspections were, you know, we're talking about the large tour buses and the 18 wheelers that. That pull the cargo out of the ports.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
For the amount. Yeah. Okay, so that one is for the 27 positions. It'll be 5,505,000. Excuse me.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Okay, so, yeah, for the 27 position to ask us for FY26. 5. $5,125,999. That's what the initial costs of all the equipments and vehicles that we would need. Then in FY27, that cost drops down to $3,196,696.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Your question on this subject matter. That is that island statewide or just Honolulu program?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Initially, it's just Honolulu. We're going to start off with Honolulu first.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay. Is highway enforcement. Why would you do just highway enforcement? You said enforcement.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yes. So DOT had talked to HPD and they were in agreement to it because they said they were so short in staffing also. So DOT wanted us to complement or supplement HPD in this area.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Well, that's fine. And. Well, but when you have a duplicate system, that means duplicate everything Duplicated. Right.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
And that's managed by the city and by the county. On the Police Department, they're the one. That's their jurisdiction.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Yeah. So isn't it better that they get amount of people that they need instead of us creating a whole nother level with cars and insurance and everything else and having DUIs and speeding?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And we do that now. We actually do that now in areas where we have presence. For example, at the airport. You know, we do DUI enforcement and.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
That's not on the road. I mean, it's on Nimitz highway and Lagoon Drive and that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
It is limited. Yes. Our Harbor Patrol does the same thing. Our central patrol also does speed enforcements on the street. So. So the Department of Law Enforcement, we actually have statewide jurisdiction, you know, concurrent with the county jurisdiction.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Understand. But you're asking us for millions to shore it up to, to duplicate what the police is doing statewide. I mean, island wide.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Correct. But this is also going to be U funded. So DOT had indicated that were going to use federal funds for this.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Not to my knowledge. Not General Fund. No, it's not. It's not General funded. This is all you funded.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
And it's going to be that way. Not. You're not going to come back in the future and say we don't have the funds now we got to, you guys got to stop.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Another question further to continue. So is the city and county giving up the police jurisdiction on DUIs then?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No, she just said it's going to be federal funds paying for it. Yeah.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Okay, next crazy question. So, so you know if you pull over on truck, you guys also doing weight overweight on those roads and then you, you guys would be doing the fines across the board. How does those funds, what does those funds go?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So what would. Right now DOT has inspectors, but they don't have any law enforcement authority. So what DOT is envisioning is that we will have deputies with their inspectors working some of the stations. But also if it necessitates pulling one of the trucks over, we, we have the authority to do that. But the inspector does not.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So, so, but what he's saying is so if you pull them over, I don't know, maybe the, the, the cargo.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Is overweight, but you're going to pull them over at the request of the inspector.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Correct. And we're also going to be cross trained. There's a federal program that train the same training that the DOT inspector has. Our deputies that are assigned to that unit will also have.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
We, we passed a law that says you cannot have these big trucks from a certain time and that they cannot be in the left lane. Or is that what you're going to enforce? Nobody enforces it.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Now we're gonna, we're gonna enforce all regulations that relates to commercial vehicles with dot.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay. So you're gonna, you're gonna actually enforce these laws that I just brought up because nobody's doing.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
That law is kind of, kind of vague. Yeah. Because it's the large. If there's nobody on the lane, then the large truck can be there or if there's few cars on the lane in the lane, then the large truck can be there. So I'm not sure you know how you argue what's few.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Well, yeah, you try going to eight in the morning, nine in the morning, you see these big trucks and it's with bumper to bumper.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
It's the middle though. I mean the extremes are easy. It's the middle that's going to be hard to do. I don't know who makes the judgment calling about the middle.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I, I don't know the specifics on the regulation? No. Well, they don't have the team yet for the highway. No, we do existing traffic enforcement, not the. But not the commercial vehicles. My. Our deputies are not trained in that yet.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
They just don't. But we're not. We're not doing that right now.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
For your going back to the law enforcement. Well, the traffic enforcement requests. Does that mean you would also have to stand up new training materials or new recruit classes? Or can you fold that into your existing training and recruit classes?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Some of it's overlapping, but the commercial vehicle inspections will be new and the accident investigations would be new and everything.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Question. Sorry. The construction of the police facility in Leeward Oahu, any particular location that you guys are considering? Leroux is kind of big. Any.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We were hoping to find a location in Waianae. Waianae area.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
What we really wanted to do was not only build the police facility there, but also have some type of mental health evaluation facility there or a safe center there where instead of actually having to take somebody into custody, maybe we can find treatment for them or an alternative for them as opposed to going into the system depending on the violation.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
I'm curious. You know, for your, your top priorities is to get the different, or I guess the increase in salary for your officers. What, what is it that you still need to figure out to. To make that a reality?
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
Because we can give the money, but if there's a second mechanism that needs to happen, does it have to be collectively bargained or is this a differential? Like what. What's the method that we're. You're trying to get to?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So, so my, My understanding is it has to be done prior to the master agreement for the. This upcoming collective bargaining. So I, they are working on some type of supplemental agreement.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
So it's a supplemental agreement only with your div. Your Department. Correct. Your sheriffs. So does it. Because you're, you're only. Well, it's the. There's a bargaining unit for state law enforcement, so I would assume that's sheriffs and then officers. Right. So you only. You're only doing this for sheriffs then? Correct. But we're not.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
So it's not a collective bargaining. It's just a supplemental for just sheriffs then?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
That's the mechanism that I understand is how they're trying to do.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
So there was no discussion about all of what is it unit 1514 going in together to just increase the salaries for everybody because I assume our ACOs are having a hard time recruiting.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, right now do care's rating is two srs above the sheriff's. Interesting. Yeah.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
Okay, so you think this, this will happen then? Because I think it's important. We got to do it. It's just, you know, we don't want to add to this said happened in you need to happen 2006. It's 202425.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I can only say I'm hopeful and optimistic that it will happen because it will help our staffing shortages and our recruitment if we can get closer to what the county is paying their officers.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
Well, but the counties also still have humongous vacancies as well in the police departments.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
No, absolutely. But if we're 24 to $30,000 behind in annual salaries from the county, we will. We don't even have a chance.
- Troy Hashimoto
Legislator
No, I agree. And so I think this is like a time factor. Right. We got. If this doesn't work, we got to figure something else out because there's some sense of urgency here. So. Okay, absolutely.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Just to add to that. So this is just for the deputy sheriffs and the different levels of deputy sheriffs that you're asking for the increases.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So all your vacancies. I noticed there's no amount there. So you're waiting to get plug in from what you're able to negotiate.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
If you know, we're adding on this portion of you know, trucks, speeding and all this. Where does that leave the ag crimes as your priority? As one of the priorities as we address that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Right. It, it'll be a totally different section. Which, which is why, you know, we, we, we, we do have a request for that. For, for the A crimes. We're requesting 46 FTEs which include Deputy sheriffs and investigators to have presence to patrol the A crime.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I mean the agricultural lands, the, you know, and, and to have investigators to do the follow up investigations. Anytime you know, there's an assault or a theft, you know, of equipment or agricultural products.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
That's been some of the issues. So when Claire was ag, you know, a lot of these issues came up. And so she was one of the ones that helped draft the Bill to make sure that we could at least enforce areas where the county was. Was had very little presence, usually on private lands.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
In dhh Legislature passed a Bill that's now law and silver alert. So you have 250,000, but the program's not even launched. Do you have an update?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yes. So right now we're waiting for responses from our MOUs with the. The various county police departments. We are talking with Hyema to determine whether they want to activate the alert on their system or whether they want to give us access to do the alerts.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And then the other thing is, hopefully in two weeks I will have a coordinator hired.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah, but you don't have control to the system that taxes everybody and all of that. We do not.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We have to go through Hyma for that. So that. That's. We've had meetings with DoD to determine what they prefer. And we'll go with whatever they prefer. You know, if they want us to do it, we'll. We'll have our coordinator do it. You know, obviously after all the criterias are reviewed and met. So we're close.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah. Thank you. Because there's been more and more. Yeah, you see lots of these little posters of senior citizens who will. They took a walk and because they have dementia, you can't find them.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Question your forensic lab. So you're expanding the lab. What do you cover in your forensic lab right now? And what are you asking for?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Right now we have a narcotics lab that does analysis mainly for just drugs as part of our request for the explosive enforcement, especially for fireworks. You know, we want to expand the lab, you know, to be able to analyze the different explosive materials and chemicals which are a requirement for criminal prosecution of these cases.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And then we also want to expand to firearms. Firearms testing and the nibing machine. So that way we could also address the gun violence.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So the lab tests for what though? Like the. I don't know the composition. The composition. Then your. Your penalties are high or it affects the penalties depending on.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
He's saying that until they do the analysis, they can't prosecute.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yeah. So you don't prosecute at all now from being. They don't prosecute. Yeah, but what do you Right.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Right now we are going to the Honolulu Police Department SIS section. They've been very helpful but they're overwhelmed with all of their cases too.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we felt that it was time for us to be self sufficient and because we are recovering so much fire, so many fireworks and the different cases that it would just, it's going to be more timely for the prosecutions, which is what we're really after.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah, because once you prosecute then you know it sends a message. Correct. There's publicity about it.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
On the notion of fireworks. So in addition to that question, you also from your report from the legal fireworks task force recommended a fireworks enforcement division. So is that included in your budget request here or is that after the fact?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
That that was after the fact. But we do have the form A's which we can submit to you.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
Do you have a rough estimate? Because I think you're asking for positions and there was a funding for that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we are to, to include the forensic laboratory. The first year startup costs would be $5,168,977. For FY27 it would be $2,333,054.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Correct. The estimate cost of the lab is approximately $2 million. That's the nostalgic. Thank you.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
It should be one administrator, two admin staff and five investigators.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We, we redescribe current positions in anticipation of this to run. We were planning to try to stand up a forensic laboratory before all of this. And we have redescribed current positions already existing positions that we have to run the lab.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Position number. They don't have anybody there. They took old positions and redesigned.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No, they have a narcotics running that too. You don't have a forensic lab? No. Yeah, they have the narcotics lab.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah, I know. I have a question though, so I'm going to ask. I have. I wanted to follow up on a conversation we had about expanding the task force to look at homemade bombs and how do we figure out a way to identify material being shipped for those homelanders. So if you guys can.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And hopefully you had some time to think about that because right now the task force is very specific. But it seems like there's the problem has expanded much larger than that and there's a lot of homemade bombs. So have you thought about what you could do to try to Address that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we, that, that that explosive enforcement section would do both. Okay. Because they're, they're related. So a lot of times when you look at IEDs, one of the simpler ways to get the explosive filler is they take apart the fireworks.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So they, they'll use the lift charge, the black powder as the filler force, for example, for the pipe bomb, or don't, although it's a lot less. They'll use the flash powder, which is the report of the aerial device, and mix that in to use as the filler for the device.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Because really what you really need is you need fuel to burn rapidly or the explosive material to burn rapidly and then you have confinement and once you have that, it's going to detonate. So that's, that's one way they can make homemade devices or we refer to them as IEDs.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
The other way they can do it is if they have any proficiency in chemistry and they get the appropriate ingredients and they mix it and they use that as the filler. Or they'll, they'll take, you know, either say stolen explosives, certain grades of fertilizer, and they'll mix it with another ingredient again to make either.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Normally that you'll get a Low explosives versus the high explosives, but they'll use that as, as the filler for your device.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, but for you guys to address that, that's already covered in some of the additional requests you're making. Or is that something would have to be on top of that?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay. Yeah. And then what about the tech equipment, you know, the surveillance equipment that you're using to scan as many containers as possible. Any adjustment there, or if we were.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Actually to start to use the large scale scanners, that would have to be a different request because that, those would come, are really costly, they run in the millions.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But. Okay, but don't you, we may need to do that though, right? Because, and I'm not trying to spend more money, but we may need to do that because my understanding is a lot of the, the staff who are at the ports who may be able to identify certain containers because of threats, your tips have basically diminished.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Now you, you don't have the same amount of information that you used to have. So now we have to replace the flow of getting, gathering that information with something else that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
That is, that is correct. We will need another technology solution to do that. If we were to actually get that type of X ray or particle scanner, you would probably, we would probably have a higher success rate in stopping illegal Fireworks coming into the state.
- Carol Fukunaga
Legislator
I have a follow up question to your comment. Has the Department also reached out to some of the shipping companies and Department of Transportation?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Those people are now threatened not to speak to them and provide tips.
- Carol Fukunaga
Legislator
And so that's for the management of those companies, the people who used to.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Provide information so that they could identify where some of this illegal activity or product was. They no longer talk.
- Carol Fukunaga
Legislator
Okay, but then to what extent are the heads of the shipping companies participating and working with your law enforcement team to be able to crack down on. This kind of activity under management?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I mean, is the management going to say you got to tell them no matter what?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
You know, I think the best way to answer that question is we will use all investigative strategies to interdict. Yeah. Without really going into specifics, you know, of who we talk to, who we don't talk to, how we identify shipments, how we, whether we're going to use explosive detection.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Can a lot of this overlaps about security anyway. And so the investment to me could be worth it if you're going to start looking for, you know, biosecurity issues ahead of time. And the fireworks issue, I mean it's going to be the same equipment. I would assume it is. Yeah, but it's very expensive from what I understand.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I know but you know, one, I mean Senator, to go in one wrong bug and that's also very expensive. But we can talk about that later. I think what we'll probably have to do is introduce a Bill so maybe Senator Funaga comment on requiring then the management and then if you don't do it there's penalties.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
But this discussion, discussion chair did say that you have the test force. So a lot of the things he recommended probably you can bring it up at the test.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No, that's the problem is we have to expand the task force.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
You're asking for what, $1.2 million this year for the task force. But can I go back to my original question when you talked about the prosecution with regards to taking over some of the responsibilities on the highways thing and you were saying that you, you would prosecute, but you don't have prosecution responsibilities. A.G.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
no, I, I meant to stay prosecute all of our cases. Yeah, go, go, go to the ags. Yeah.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And this is, this seems to be a trend unfortunately where you know, the prosecutor is no longer taking many of the, the cases that involve mislead. And so now the AG is having to ramp up, you know, the, unfortunately HPD seen short staff and so now the State has. They're not doing AG theft.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
They're not doing some of these things. And a lot of this was exposed during COVID too, which is why, like I said, the former AG ended up saying, well, there's going to be a huge vacuum if we don't. If we don't provide some kind of law enforcement at the state level. Right.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And please understand. I'm sorry. Good. Please understand. Our current illegal fireworks task force really consists of two investigators, you know, trying to complete this whole mission. And.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And what happens is, you know, once we determine that an operation is needed, then we rally up all the troops from all of the other departments, and they all step to the plate to help. But it's really just two individuals, you know, which is why we need to.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But because of the lack of the information being discontinued, you went from what, 200 something thousand pounds to only 40,000 pounds?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And that's a lot of. That was due to the fact that you no longer have the information you need.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, part of it, too, was, I think, after the initial seizures in 2023, the criminal element will adjust. Right. If they figured out that we found her method of smuggling, they're going to adjust their method of smuggling. And so now we have to adjust our strategy, you know, to catch them.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
A couple questions. One, my understanding is some of the illegal fireworks are coming in on planes. Are those commercial passenger airliners in the. In the cargo hold, or are they on. On just cargo planes? And how dangerous is that? I guess that's what I'm really driving at.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we're catching daily, almost daily parcels from the U.S. postal Service containing 8,000 pounds of, maybe 200 pounds of fireworks at a time. And those are coming on our commercial planes, and those are personal delivery.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
I guess my recollection was at the Lockerbie flight, you know, 40 years and 35 years ago, the explosive was the size of, like, a cassette, for those who are old enough to remember what a cassette deck is. But it wasn't very big, and it brought down a 747. Is this something we should be losing sleep about?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I would be concerned. The Lockerbury flight, probably, if. Describing the size that you had. You had indicated was probably high explosives. Okay, so the fireworks are not as. As potent. It depends on the confinement. It depends on how much you have.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Okay, so if you're asking whether a parcel of fireworks can take a plane down, it really, there's a lot of factors you have to look at. You know, how much of A fire. Did it start? What. The location, you know, in relation to, you know, to the side of the plane. All of that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
All of that makes a difference. But it's. It's a bad day if you have fireworks going off in the cargo plane. Yeah.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
So one final question. It's. Okay, so if you can't. If you. If you. If you encounter. And if you encounter illegal fireworks in a shipping container, for instance, and you can't figure out who. Who is shipping it and where it's going to, you can still just confiscate it. Right. You don't have to. There's no attempt to.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
So even if you don't, even if there is no prosecution, you still take the stuff off the street, correct?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We will still. We will still seize the illegal fireworks. We. We will always try to do an historical investigation on the shipment. And once it's no longer determined as evidence, then we have to go through the task of disposing of it, which in itself is very problematic. Okay. All right. Thanks, George.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We had one estimate to dispose of. I want to say it was about 148,000 pounds of fireworks and it was slightly over $1.0 million.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
They're doing drones now. Some of them are doing drones now. Drones.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, so. So there. There's really three recommended methods to dispose of fireworks. The first one depend. And. And again, it depends on the type of fireworks. Like your mortar shelves you cannot burn. So we would countercharge, you know, the other fireworks we would burn or you function it as design.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
You might need legislation to allow that, though. Correct.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And there's probably huge liability issues on that because we're selling product that's considered illegal. You're going to have product that might be classified as 1.4 consumer fireworks, but they're overloaded, so you don't know what's going to happen when you light it off. So all of that factors in on whether we would actually, you know. Yeah, try.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
All that stuff in that warehouse. Because you can't sell it, the old furniture, whatever. So we need law to. To sell it. No, you can't sell it.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
I'd like to go back to Senator Fukunaga's question with regards to the Shipping, we all know that the foreign ships can come into the island waters. So we know that China, if the fireworks are coming in, it goes to the ports of anywhere on the mainland.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So the transport for the shipments all go to, whether it's Pasha or Matson or whoever. So I think a lot of the investigations of the shipping issues, too, I think you guys got to go to the mainland and see where all these things are being unloaded, particularly those labeled as coming from a foreign country like China.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So whether it's the. The stopping of shipments, either East Coast or West Coast, but I think most of them come in via the West Coast ports.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So for that part, on the investigations of where these shipments are coming from via maritime, looking at the ports, the only thing I can see is I think issues like the airlines and those personal shipments coming is pretty hard to detect. But, boy, you guys got.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
You guys got a lot of problems and issues and more of an activity that you probably will have to have a lot more people, you know, doing.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
The technology helps though, right? It's really the technology that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So just one question on if it costs $1.0 million to dispose. When, when you confiscate, can you charge back to whomever you confiscate from so that there's some payment for disposal, or do you know who they are? I suppose.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I guess the question should be, what legislation do you need so you can do that? I mean, right, okay. Because. No. So you can do that now? Yes, you can do that now. Have you done it? Have you charged anybody? Everything is under investigation.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
But when you finish, I mean, with. With whoever you confiscate from, you can charge back.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
He's saying it's under investigation. So you got a sidebar conversation.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And those individuals, we can probably go back and charge them for disposal charges. But those were not the container cases. No.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So all those companies that are selling fireworks during the holidays, particularly after Christmas and New Year's, do you folks send investigators to see what they're selling on the retail market?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So with legislation last year, we now have inspection rights, and they are now required to keep what we call an A and D acquisition disposition book. So we can look at those records.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Thank you. Okay, we're going to recess. Okay, go ahead then. I thought everybody looked bad.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
You know, I didn't realize there's enough fireworks. So you guys know of a machine that they actually use to. As a scanner to run on containers and how Much. Is that.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Yeah, because if you're disposing at a million, I think the investment would be worth it.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So Customs and Border Protection already has that for the foreign cargo. So we can. We can get a cost for you on that.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay. My question is, how does a new entity like you folks rack up in three months $135,983 in overpayments?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Because we inherited that from Department of Public Safety. So what happened was once, once the sheriff's division and the other units came over on January 12024 we did our due diligence in auditing all of. All of the leave records and payment records and the overtime. Okay. So that's how we uncovered a lot of these overpayments.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay, so you came into being in January and. And it was.0000 all the way until September 2024. All of a sudden it goes up to $87290. So you found that many from all those months. You found it in September and you posted it. None of it was new. New overpayments.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
And then in October, it went up to 135,000. One month later, 135,983. Correct. So you found more or you had your own overpayments?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
No, I think a small portion of it is, but the majority of it, we. It came from prior to January 1st.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Get all the records? We're still waiting for portions of records. So as we get there when we audit.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay. It's just odd that it would take that many months. And then September you only got a portion of. In October, another portion, and then November it was carried over. But these employees who have been overpaid are with you now?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
The smaller amounts of the overpayments usually happens. We find it when they retire. But there are active cases. So what relating to the overpayment?
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay. The law is clear. Are you aware of the law? If we overpay, we can go in and collect X amount, X percentage to pay it off. And if it's under a certain amount, you can collect it all at once or you can collect it. I think it was $50 a paycheck.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
So what are you doing to Collect it. Actively doing to collect the state your name. The division is the fiscal.
- Thomas Yamamoto
Person
Hi, my name is Thomas Yamamoto. I'm the fiscal officer for the Department. In regards to overpayments, we. We follow DAGS comptroller. Zero, sorry, say that again. We. We follow the comptroller memoranda on how to.
- Thomas Yamamoto
Person
So we reach out to the individual. The individual, and we come up with a settlement plan according to the parameters set by dags, and we follow that for repayment purposes. Okay?
- Donna Kim
Legislator
So DAGS told us just today that it's up to each Department. Okay. And they do put our memorandum, but it's up to each Department. And accordingly, there's a law that says you can collect X amount if it's under so much. You can collect up to a certain percentage after a higher amount.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
But the departments, as far as I know, has not been utilizing that. And they've been charging like $25 a paycheck. And so some of these people have been paying for years $25, and then they retire, whatever, and then you cannot collect the money.
- Thomas Yamamoto
Person
There are several. We send in a report monthly with the eggs. And I believe if they said if we negotiate like a price that the. That the person who got overpaid was okay with, then they can pay back however much they want to. But I believe after a certain amount, it's like 25% of their base pay.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
I think it's more than that. You should go check the law, because I know we, we. I actually increased it and it was signed into law so we can collect a lot more, but it's not been done.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Well, it doesn't have to be agreed to. You have DAGS have the control of the potential. So when we overpay, we should be able to. To take that money out. So when we underpay, we have to immediately make them whole and pay it immediately.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Not $25, a check to give to make up the money that we didn't pay them and vice versa, when we overpay them. The law is clear on how much you can get. You don't have to have an agreement because the checks are cut by dags.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Try from you guys. And you folks should be very familiar with how much you can take, how much you can get back. I mean, we're talking over $1.0 million with all the departments. And you folks have being you have one of the higher ones.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
So there needs to be a better effort in recouping these funds because they are.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
This is overpayments that you inherited. Right. It was the previous Department.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
But it's current employees that owe the money. So it's your employees, current employees that owe the funds. And now it's up to you, the Department, according to dags, to be able to recoup these funds. Or maybe we can just take it out of your budget. Can we see what actions you're actually doing and how much you've collecting?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yeah, we could do that. And, and, and another thing is that from, we inherited things from PSD as well and they had agreements with some of the employees as well. So it's hard to break those agreements.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Okay. But the whole issue, and I know this very well because the law states you don't have to have an agreement.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We will resolve it and provide you the information once we get it.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
To follow up on Senator Kim's comments with regards to, and very troubling that she's saying that if, if there's an arrangement for a payback of $25 a month, that person retires and what happens? Perhaps there should be a Bill to change that.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
That upon retirement that all x all that's due to the state is paid out of before retirement checks are sent out.
- Thomas Yamamoto
Person
It's sent to the, excuse me, it's sent to the AGs if they retire. Yeah.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Do we know, do we know though that that's been done, that there's. They've been paying before retirement?
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Yeah, they have a list of the people and how much they're paying because I've seen. And what about retirement? It's $25. Well, after that, then it has to go to collection and the AG's got to go after them and it's not high on their priorities. So if they are.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So if they retire, why don't we have a Bill or a law to say that before retirement any excess that's due the state be taken out of the retirement.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
And it's not just retirement. It's like, you know, you know, hspa, they can take all their vacation and stuff.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, we can do, maybe we'll do, maybe we'll do an info briefing on overpayment later because we surely should be hearing about their budget. They're not going to be able to solve it right now because at the, at, at the Same point.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I mean, they should be applauded for the fact that they did the audit and, and found it. Because if not, if they just took it over, they wouldn't have even known about it.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
No, because I would have said public works. Why is your public safety. Why is your numbers now lower? Where is it going? No, but it's. But if you look at what public safety, you look at their numbers and they've always had a high carryover.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah. These are ones they fought they. When they audited the paperwork, when they got from Public Safety, the former Department of Public Safety, that's when they started finding it.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
So what does this tell us then? That. Well, I'm just saying. What does it tell us? That there's a lot more overpayments than what's on this record then. Because this record has $1.0 million plus.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So if we're finding out if the departments aren't auditing. You may be right.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Yeah. So we're talking several $1.0 million of monies that is being given out that we not entitled to.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
I just got one other question on going Back to table 15, your CIP request. I'm sorry if I missed this earlier. Okay, so for your construction and equipment for the receiving desk, airport section 16.6 over the next two fiscal years. You guys already have a site identified for that and if so, where in particular?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
It's. It's by the airport. The old enterprise. Zero, the old enterprise. Across from the Dunkin Donuts complex, right across the leverage.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
Okay. And then the 4. The 4 million for your law enforcement training selection. You don't have a site yet? We do not have a site yet. Okay, thank you.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Just a follow on question. The status of the $4 million. The relocation we gave you last time, what does that bought you? Or is that a site that you're using? Or is that rental? What's happening with that?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we are using those funds for our planning and design. We have already put out an RFP on that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We're still living in Ki street for receiving desk. And so you haven't. And at the airport we have not moved yet.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Any other questions? Okay, we're going to recess for dod. Thank you. Thank you.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, reconvening. So now we hear from the Department of Defense who will present their biennium budget requests. Good afternoon. Happy New Year.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Hey, Chair Dela Cruz, Vice Chair Moriwaki, Chair Elefante, Vice Chair Wakai, and Committee Members. I'm Major General Steve Logan, the Adjutant General for the State of Hawaii Department of Defense. Aloha, good afternoon, and Happy New Year. The following informational briefing provides the department's budget request for state fiscal years 2026 and 2027.
- Stephen Logan
Person
There's been some considerable turnover within the Department of Defense, so please allow me a moment to introduce the team that I brought with me today. To my left is Brigadier--correction--Brigadier General Phillip Mallory, the Deputy Adjutant General for the State of Hawaii, call sign Buddha.
- Stephen Logan
Person
I have the Chief of Staff of the Hawaii National Guard, Colonel Ronald Hogsten, the Director of Staff of the Hawaii Air National Guard, Colonel Shane Nagatani, call sign Nuke, Administrator of the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency, Colonel Retired James Barros, the Administrator of Community Programs that oversees the Youth Challenge and Job Challenge Academies, Brigadier General Retired Bruce Oliveria.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Director of the Office of Veteran Services, Lieutenant Colonel John Alamodin, Military Support Officer, Brigadier General Retired Neal Mitsuyoshi, our Administrative Services Officers, Colonel Retired Rusty Spray, and our Chief Engineering Officer, Major Shao Lee. So the primary mission of the State of Hawaii Department of Defense is to enable a safe and thriving state and nation.
- Stephen Logan
Person
We're a very small department with a relatively small state budget, but it's important to highlight that a little small, the State of Hawaii Department of Defense has a significant mission and that matching state funds provide access to significant federal funding. The department requests approximately $40.5 million in state funding for state fiscal year 2026, and these funds would bring in approximately $74 million in matching federal funds.
- Stephen Logan
Person
This funding would allow the department to manage its 411 open projects against an approximate $2.3 billion in federal grants. And I'll cover that a little bit more fully later on in my testimony.
- Stephen Logan
Person
The major adjustments contained in the budget request focus on sustainment, safety, and reorganization based on lessons learned from the Maui wildfires. These adjustments include approximately $1.3 million in recurring funds to sustain the department's software, hardware, cloud services, and maintenance. Prior to this year, the department was forced to sustain this by using personal vacancy savings.
- Stephen Logan
Person
However, the department can no longer internally sustain its IT fiscal requirements. These are fully articulated in Departmental Priorities Number 1 and 2 with the Form A's that were already submitted. For Number Two, The Hawaii Emergency Management Agency requests $2.7 million to provide funding support for 32 core emergency management positions.
- Stephen Logan
Person
The requested additional state funding for HIEMA personal positions is critical to sustain emergency management, planning, response, recovery, and mitigation efforts statewide including direct support for the four Hawaii counties while administering those 411 FEMA grant-funded projects equating to approximately $2.3 billion. These are articulated in the Form A's and are annotated under Departmental Priorities 13 and 14.
- Stephen Logan
Person
The Hawaii Army National Guard requires three new positions and approval to upgrade four existing positions. All of this is 100% federally funded at no expense to the state. The Hawaii National Guard Youth Challenge Program positions are funded in accordance with the National Guard Youth Challenge Program Cooperative Agreement Program.
- Stephen Logan
Person
The National Guard Bureau supports this program with 75% federal cost share with the state providing a 25% match. The current federal funding appropriation is insufficient to incorporate state-required federal payroll fringe for all program employees.
- Stephen Logan
Person
These are clearly--are fully articulated with Form A's and Departmental Priority Number 8, and salary increases for our folks to bring them up to the appropriate wage is articulated in Departmental Priority Number 17. The program is unable to hire or retrain--or retain all of its required employees at full-time salaried rates, and 44 employees are currently budgeted at an hourly rate or 89-day higher due to the lack of the federal funds that cover the fringe rate.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Because of this, the Youth Challenge Program is requesting an additional $1.9 million to pay the federal portion of the state-mandated fringe benefits. This will allow compliance with staffing supervision requirements and ensure cadet safety for the 24 hours a day, seven days a week at both our campuses. CIP is more clearly articulated in Table 15.
- Stephen Logan
Person
The Governor's Budget approved eight of our 12 CIP projects requested for a total of $61.8 million in FY26 and $19.5 million in FY27 for general obligation bond funds, respectively, to match the $62.7 million in FY26 and $17.7 million in other federal funds for both of those fiscal years.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Overall and in summary, the Governor's Budget approved a total of $81.4 million in general obligation funds for both years and 80.5 million in other federal funds for our vacancies. DOD has a total of 504 authorized positions, 292 permanent, and 212 temporary.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Our total vacancies are 142 or 29% of our overall manning, trending downward by 43 from last fiscal year, which represents a 28% reduction. So we've definitely turned the corner of our vacancies and we're on path to meet our 5% vacancy rate goal that I've established as the new Adjutant General.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Of these 142 positions, 30 are 100% federally funded and 65 are 75% federally funded. So the following is a status breakdown for the vacancies. 24 positions are being established--they were fairly new--and the descriptions and classifications are being worked.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Eight positions are being redescribed due to the inability to fill--inability to fill them at their current described position description. 24 positions are awaiting state matching funds which are also included in our budget request. 26 positions are filled by the hourly or exempt hourly wage employees or 89-day hires.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Eighteen of those are from the Youth Challenge Academy that I previously described, and there's four others that are also at that rate. Fifteen positions are awaiting DHRD classification and 48 positions are pending hiring actions. I have the breakdown, but it's, but it's anywhere between an internal vacancy announcement, pending the internal interviews, pending civil service interviews, or the conditional offer being given to the individuals.
- Stephen Logan
Person
For telework, of the 362 current employees, one employee is authorized for telework for reasonable accommodation purposes. Thank you for this opportunity to present the Department of Defense's budget requests, and we're available to answer any questions that the committees may have.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Maybe you can go over Table 6 and just explain what you want added to the budget.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Okay, so I briefly mentioned some of the items that are contained on Table Six.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
You can--you talked about it. We--just say previously mentioned, then we can move on.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Okay. So I previously briefed Departmental Priority Numbers 1 and 2. Number Four is a distributed antenna systems, system upgrade. It's a little bit of money, but it'll give us a greater communicative link that we can, that we can communicate. Number Five is a new salary schedule for the engineer classification.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Number Six is also a new accountant position. Number Eight I previously briefed for the fringe request for the Youth Challenge Academy. Seventeen I briefed for the salary increases. Thirty-Four is the upgrades for the--with federal funds--for the CFMO or our facility management office engineer position upgrades. Number--Departmental Priority Number 36 establishes a new engineer position.
- Stephen Logan
Person
39, a pest technician position. Number 40 is a visitor control technician position. Twelve speaks to building maintenance supervisor positions. Thirteen and 14 is to reorganize HIEMA, and I mentioned that in my original testimony.
- Stephen Logan
Person
Sixteen is for the Limited English Proficiency Program position, which is mandated to us, but it's for a position to enable folks to get after emergency management and response capabilities if their English is not their first language. And I think that covers the numbered departmental priorities.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
I have one. So could you explain your Siren modernization at five million or actually $10M? What does that cover and is it statewide? How are you connected with other departments that are also using SIREN modernization funding?
- Stephen Logan
Person
Okay, well, it--in effect, we identified a lot of concerns with our Siren Program after the Maui wildland fires, but I'll bring up Administrator Barros and he can go into greater detail on the--on the application of those, of those program funds.
- James Barros
Person
Aloha. We use the Siren CIP money to install new sirens, we use it to upgrade existing sirens that require contracting support--and those are the Rule Two that we use it for--the installation of new sirens, and the upgrade for our current system.
- James Barros
Person
Private state land, county land. We do have a map on HIEMA that shows the exact location of all our sirens across the state. So it, it depends on where we're putting it. Sometimes we have to deal with Department of Transportation, highways to get land, and we'll put a siren there or private land and do a MOU with them for--to install a siren.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
So when you install these, you're working with the counties and so that everybody is clear on what the siren means and being able to be alerted so we don't have a situation like in Maui?
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
And this $10M covers the whole state or are you coming back for more funding? But ten million covers the state?
- James Barros
Person
Yes, because we will phase it in. So, for example, this year, we're getting after some tsunami sirens that will be fixed within the next four months. There's also a work order with DAGS right now with about six sirens or replacing our very old sirens that are being replaced. So this would be the money for the next phase of modernization and upgrades.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Just to follow up regarding the topic, so the existing sirens, they're all existing, but according to what your plans are, as an example this year, how many were new installations, aside from just upgrading the old ones?
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Okay. And when you talk about the tsunami sirens, that's only those that are located on seawards, yeah?
- James Barros
Person
Yes, The inundation zones, that's, that's pretty much our priority right now is get those sirens replaced immediately.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
And make sure that it covers whether it's farthest away in communities such as the Big Island in Ka'u, but everywhere where there is the oceans on the tsunami zone areas. Thank you so much.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Just as a follow up, you know, I know that you folks have old sirens. How many of them are obsolete that you guys cannot find parts for? And trying to work with the county, I know like we had some issues in Pa'ia because of permitting. How, how fast or how are you guys able to work with them now that has moved a lot of these projects forward?
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
And if you had to--I'll just wrap another question--if you had to put sirens in all these new areas for every place in the tsunami area--because I know that we've had challenges in the other areas that everybody wants on siren--what would be the total cost and how many of them would be needed?
- James Barros
Person
We can get that number for you. On the total amount that we're looking at, right now the HIEMA team looks at our sirens program and if we fix our tsunami sirens that currently exist, we'll get coverage in the correct areas. We do want to modernize the sirens.
- James Barros
Person
So that's part of the, the money for the ask cause the sirens that are very old on our map, they show as black, that they don't even work anymore. And some of them are older than General Logan, so...oh, sir.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
Just to clarify, so you have different sirens for like tsunami or wildfire, or is this one siren and you have different beeps or whatever?
- James Barros
Person
But when we look at where they're placed, we count those in an inundation zone as a, as a tsunami siren.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
So you have wildfire zones or you have tsunami zones and it's just where you place them, but that's the same siren?
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
And your siren budget, does that include--because I know you had issues with security and perimeter fencing, so does that include all of that too?
- James Barros
Person
No, it doesn't, Senator. What we're doing is we're--the modernization is getting better casing and a little bit higher.
- James Barros
Person
We don't think so. Right now we're talking to the counties--you know like how the Highways Division has Adopt a Highway? We're now socializing with the communities to say, 'hey, this is your siren. Adopt a siren.' So we don't think fencing for a permanent siren is required.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
And normally your tsunami sirens are all along the highways anyway or close to the highways?
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
And I don't think there have been damages to the tsunami signs that I know because I travel the island and I see those, but I, I haven't seen, you know, any in, you know, any inference with regards to damages, whatever.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Or at least close to the ocean, right? So I wanted to go back to the Maui situation. The talk has always been about on fire siren. Is that conversation still going on with you guys in the County of Maui?
- James Barros
Person
No, we--right after the fire, the Governor convened the emergency management, all the administrators and the county mayors, and we do have a protocol for sirens on who's responsible and what threat, and it's a, all-hazard siren. It'll go off and it just alerts our citizens to check their TV, check their cell phone, check the first responders. Something's happening.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So just to be clear, it's not an actual siren that like a tsunami siren, but phone alerts, social media alert is what they're looking at as a fire breaks out.
- James Barros
Person
It would, it would be a siren that's in, in the neighborhood that would go off that where we test, you know, on the first of every month. That would just alert our citizens to check other sources. Something, something is happening in your area.
- James Barros
Person
Per siren, right now we're estimate that we can fix an existing siren for just under 3,000, about 3000, 4,000. Modernize.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Okay. So are you using the same siren as a tsunami siren for that alert or is this a separate siren? It is the same? Just different picture of alert or--
- James Barros
Person
No, no, just--same alert, just different location. So the, the siren that's on the ocean would make the same sound as the siren in the mountain and it's just alerting the citizens, 'hey, something's happening here.'
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Are they up already on certain islands or it's a projection of future placements?
- James Barros
Person
Statewide, yes. And when you look at the map, you'll see where they're located from Mauka to Makai, all of our sirens.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So in reference to the issue with the wildfires on Maui and the address that Senator DeCoite brings up because she got three islands to consider, to worry about, so are they distributed already and built in certain areas in our state? And who decides where those new sirens will be placed?
- James Barros
Person
So for a new siren, it's a conversation that HIEMA will have with--
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Okay. They would decide where those placements will be then.
- James Barros
Person
Right, and then the technicians will sit down and look and say, okay. With the sound of the siren, work with the best--
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
So in reference to Senator DeCoite's question, so Maui already has those other placement to new alarm systems in, in--on Maui?
- James Barros
Person
In Lahaina, we're working to replace those sirens that were destroyed. Yes, three sirens were destroyed in the fire. We're working to replace that within a six month--
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
New ones that are out there on the fields already on any of the Tri Island?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Maybe it's better if we look at the map first and then from there we can go.
- Samantha DeCorte
Legislator
Well, I have a question. Sorry. When you folks are going to go throughout and do the repairs, do you prioritize it according to what area has the highest wildfire risk? And then also, I'm on your map right now. In my district--well, there's a few identifiers. Number One is beyond repair, which is obvious, it's beyond repair, but then you have two other categories. One says requires maintenance, the other says maintenance required. So what is the difference?
- James Barros
Person
So one, we need to contract outside of the technicians that I have. So the yellow might, I assume, fix. The red, we have to go through DAGS to get a contractor to fix those.
- Samantha DeCorte
Legislator
Okay, so then are you going to be prioritizing your siren repairs according to what community is at more risk than others?
- James Barros
Person
We look at the inundation zones of tsunami. So that's the first threat that we looked at, a tsunami threat. And that's where we want to prioritize assignments.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
I have questions on Table Four relating to your Fire Marshal. Yeah, Table Four, you have two positions for 2.2 million. So which division would the Fire Marshal be housed in?
- Stephen Logan
Person
So that's kind of an emergent theme that, that recently came up. The Fire Marshal, I believe there's a legislative proposal by which it will move to or it could move to the Department of Defense.
- Stephen Logan
Person
As quickly as we can--if it does come to the Department of Defense through this legislative session--as quickly as we can operationalize that position is how we would place it. Currently it would come under me as the, as the Adjutant General, but working very closely with the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency.
- Brandon Elefante
Legislator
Is the 2.2 for two positions or is that two positions and standing up the operations?
- Stephen Logan
Person
I believe it's two positions and standing up the operation. And there has been some controversy between the salary rate for the Fire Marshal itself, but since it doesn't currently reside with me, I haven't done a complete staffing action.
- Stephen Logan
Person
But given recent activity, the Maui wildland fires, the unfortunate fires we experienced on New Year's Day, and what most recently happened with HFD, as quickly as we can operationalize it is how we would approach it. So we're going to lean forward throughout this year, and then if successful--and it does migrate over to the Department of Defense at the end of this session--then we'll, we'll be able to hit the ground running.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
That seems awkward, though, because the, the State Fire Council is with Department of Labor and they appoint the Fire Chief, the Fire Marshal, so how does that reconcile? Or you haven't--you guys haven't discussed this yet?
- Stephen Logan
Person
Yeah, well, I think this is looking towards the future through the next fiscal year, if in fact it moves to the Department of Defense.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, so when it moves, does that mean the State Fire Council no longer appoints the Fire Marshal and it's under you?
- Stephen Logan
Person
The, the correct answer, Senator, is I don't know. I haven't done a complete staffing action on that yet.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Because then, wouldn't they--they would probably have to move the entire State Fire Council as well, I would assume, because the way we passed it, the Fire Council made up the chiefs, they determined the Fire Marshal.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Department of Labor. I guess we'll just wait to see what the bill says.
- Lorraine Inouye
Legislator
Okay. Just one closing. When I chaired the committee that overseeing your agency, there was talk about building the new building. So whatever happened to that discussion, moving out of--
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Okay, one question. The pest technician position you have as a--for 39 on Table Six, you guys, you guys have a relationship with Department of Ag because I noticed it's vector issues. Any relationship in regards?
- Stephen Logan
Person
And so, so, Senator, for this one, it's a federally funded position and it's designated for pest control on federal lands. Much of our armories and facilities are--it's either a shared response between state land, federal land, and the funding, but this would be for the federal lands that some of our facilities reside on.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Does the outreach by the Department of Ag, in this regard say, you guys combat brown tree snake? Where you guys take that snake? You guys give them to the Department of Ag under them or you guys just kill them and fly them?
- Stephen Logan
Person
I don't, I don't recall that ever happening to any of our aircraft that are returning back from some of those areas, but if it did, we would definitely call the Department of Agriculture and turn it over to them.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, we're going to adjourn and then we'll just take a ten minute break and then have Department of Ag. Thank you.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Calling to order the Joint Committee on Ways and Means and Agriculture and Environment. So this afternoon we'll hear from the Department of Ag who will give us a preview of their biennium budget request. So good afternoon. Happy New Year.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Happy New Year. And good afternoon Members of the Budget Committee, WAM Committee and AEN Ag and Environment. My name is Sharon Hurd, Chairperson of the Department of Agriculture. And if I can start by introducing the staff that's here and the SMEs that will be called on later should that be necessary. Starting with the gentleman on my.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
My left is Warren Takenaka. He's the acting ASO for the Services office. Going to go to the Agriculture Development Division. I saw Matthew Lok, Administrator Dr. Lok and he brought with him a new staff. Bun He Chung, he is the economist. Anyone else from add? Yes, it's Market Development Branch.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
We have Brendan Akamu, he's the Market Development Branch Manager, Business Development. Moving on to the. Don't think we had anyone from Ag Loan here. Did you see anybody from Aglone? Okay, so we're moving on to the Ag Resource Management Division in charge of land and water, starting with Brian Kao, Administrator. Brian, did you have. Nope.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Then moving on to the Plant Industry Division we have Jonathan Ho. He is the Plant Industry Division. Plant Quarantine Manager Carol Okada is currently the administrative Executive 5 but she's helping us with Act 231. Okay. Greg Takishima, who is our key Pesticides Manager, he woke up sick this morning so we're sorry to see him not here.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Animal industry, we have Dr. Mayera, administrator. And anyone with you today? zero yeah, Todd Low, Manager Todd Lowe from the Aquaculture Livestock Services Department branch. Anyone else?
- Sharon Hurd
Person
So we have the Quality Assurance Division which is our seventh division. And we have the administrator Dr. Leo Obaldo with him he has his hemp specialist Artemio. We go. We call him Jun. And we also have Richard Cohen who is the Commodities Measurement Standards. And I saw Keith here. Keep Keith U. From our Commodities branch.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Thank you. Committees and Committee Members, chairs, vice chairs. I really appreciate the opportunity to speak to the Governor's decision on his budget for fiscal 26 and 27. If I can begin with an update on the 10 million that was awarded in this fiscal year in Act 231 and the momentum that is building for those programs.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Biosecurity is the focus of the Department. As this was the top issue for the farmers and ranchers when they were surveyed, the biosecurity came up as the biggest concern they have. And we all know that it's an interagency effort.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
It takes all of us and it does rely on every one of our divisions to help us with the effort to, you know, kick some bug butt, as they say. So I'm going to start with just a quick overview. For the programs, There were about $7.8 million awarded. Of the 7.8 we have obligated.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
And by obligated I mean that an RFP was issued or a contract was issued or some PO was done to obligate the funds. That's 72% of the funding, which was about $5.7 million. And of the 7.8 million, we have actually encumbered in the form of a contract or some sort of procurement, about 47%.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
So I'll just go through some of the highlights of these, what we've done. The big one, the two big ones are the CRB and the lfa. So for the CRB contract that was awarded to a company called htm, they're a local company.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
And what they did in their proposal that was selected for awarding is they, we are going to, the Department of Agriculture is going to identify the trees that we have deemed to be dead or dying or no longer viable. And they will be cutting it down, disposing of it. And that's on the islands of Oahu and Kauai.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
On the island of Oahu, their contract says at least 150 trees. Now, 150 seems like a small number, but it's the 50ft and higher tree. So that's the most expensive tree to cut down and dispose.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
So if there's trees that are in the more 30 to 40 foot range, which is the more common, it's going to be cheaper. So we anticipate a greater number than 150, but it's hard to estimate at this time. So that's on Oahu, on the island of Kauai, at least 70 trees will be cut, disposed of properly.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
And because right now the main problem for crb, the dead coconut trees, the problems are on Oahu and Kauai, we included the County of Maui and Hawaii island as more outreach.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
If, if they do identify any trees between now and the end of the contract, which is one year, they will be cutting down and removing and disposing of those trees as well. And so we've covered all the different counties with The CRP disposal LFA LFA was one.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
zero, this contract was 1.1 million, I believe, for LFA, we have. We're relying on our database that was provided to us of detections.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
It was collaboration with ISCS and the Hawaii Ant Lab, as well as our own staff that have identified residential spaces that have either reported or have been detected to have LFA, as well as voluntary reports. And we've gone out there and identified and mapped them and said, okay, these houses have potential issues with lfa.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
The contractor for this is a local company called Terminix, and they have locations on all islands. So their contract that was awarded in their scope, they're going to treat at least 580 residential properties on the island of Oahu, treat at least 290 residential properties on the island of Hawaii.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
And right now the counties of Maui and Kauai would be the same. They're going to treat residential properties within both counties as determined by our plant industry staff as they arise within the course of the scope of a year. So these two major projects there are.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
The contracts are ready to go and so we should be starting service by the. Hopefully by the end of the month. If not, if there's a delay in the certification of the contracts, it'll be soon. We have. We're ready to go. Okay, so here. Yes. Can we ask questions on the item or later?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No, we should go through the table and then you can tell us all your budget requests. Okay. And then if you have a question on that specific line, then.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
I wanted to go through just the two mainstream. We can certainly review each one later. That's okay. The other thing I wanted to bring up was the. That we have been working on ag crime. Ag crime was another big issue that was identified through the survey.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
And what we've done is we've purchased a thousand no trespassing signs and there has been a poster made by DLE Department of Law Enforcement. We shared the PDF with the Ag Committees of both House and Senate. And the reason we're starting with trespassing is in discussions with DLE Directors Low and Deputy Director Radula.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
If we can stop the crime at the trespass level, we've done a lot. We can deter it at that level. We feel we can make an inroad into the whole ag crime issue. So that. Let me talk a little bit about the Akamai arrival program.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
You don't want to go into. Start. Let's go into table six.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No no, she didn't. She just. That was her opening remarks.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
The Governor saw fit and with the support of the Legislature, hopefully we can continue the $7.2 million that was awarded for the positions in the program, moving them from a one year to at least maybe a funded so that the people that do apply will have some security in the position.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So last year the Legislature passed the Bill that had 20 million. So those. There are several lines related to biosecurity. Does that equal to the total 20 million?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So the Department was able to convince the Governor that the 10 was a good start. But you still need the full 20.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
No. zero, 12 million in the positions. Yeah. We're not. The 27 million that he approved was included other programs?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No, I thought there was the Bill. Right. The biosecurity Bill had 20 million. He vetoed half the amount. So now you're coming in to. And when I'm looking at all these different number, these different lines, I think it's only two. How much of this is.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Okay. ASO tells me the total of all the biosecurity asks is 12 million.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay. So he didn't go back to the 20. Did you ask for the full 20 back?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I'm just trying to figure out what we're. What. Because when the Legislature passed the 20, the Legislature had an idea of what it wanted to get funded. So I'm trying to reconcile of what the Legislature's original intent of. Of trying to Fund the 20 versus what you're asking for. Now what. What's the difference that from Governor's Budget.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
That's true. We asked for 20. We funded 20 last year. He vetoed 10. So they didn't rebuild the 20 in their budget request?
- Sharon Hurd
Person
No, some of the items that were. Let me say that we're very happy with what we did get based on our ask. But some of the things we didn't get was a $6.5 million ask for aquaculture projects. No, I'm talking just about security one to four.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
We had $1 million for a wildlife bovine tuberculosis vaccine study. We had $1 million for a meat processing capacity study.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So number one was the 7.0 million, right. This year, 7.2 million.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, so that was part. Was that part of the Bill? Yes. Okay. And then 3.3 million, part of the Bill. Okay. The 1163,000. That's from Act 231, right?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But so what I'm suggesting is the re. When we pass the Bill, Act 231 had originally $20 million in it.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Okay. So what we did is the Governor asked us to make the decisions of where to cut. The areas that we cut were pretty much on public outreach, community programs, media. And we maintained if. If he gave us 3 million for CRB, for instance, we kept the majority of the money. We did cut it down.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
So the money that the difference between the 20 and the 10 was not. Was not in the biosecurity section. It was mostly in the public outreach section.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, but you. Did you ask for anything that was cut in this current budget?
- Sharon Hurd
Person
We did, but we know it was the bovine TB and it was the meat processing. And. But we're. I'm going to say that we are very happy with what we got.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I mean, the Legislature wanted to make sure that the public awareness component, because that's where I think we're having a difficult time, is you got to have people aware. You got to let them know what to do, give people instruction, who to call, what to look for. That part is missing.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So you can be doing all of this, but if the community at large isn't helping us, it's a big fight.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
I agree. And that's why we used some of the funding from the CRB last year to do $25,000 projects for CRB outreach in the community levels and the neighborhood. The one that I can say that I just went to was the one in Kahuku, the tree project that Daniel Anthony did.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
He had a CRB workshop, and that was at the community level. It was very well attended.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah, that's fine. But that's different than being on TV all the time and being on the radio all the time so that more people are aware, because we're. With all. Everything we're doing, I feel like we're still losing.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
You know, I mean, we're still getting calls. I know. Senator Fukunaga called yesterday, saying now she thinks Papa Kolea Makiki, all of these areas, might have some little fire ant.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
Point made. I used to be in marketing. I understand the power of outreach. We are. We are doing an interagency outreach with Anthology. We're funding them with a. But it's not TV. TV is too expensive.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Why would you hire a PR firm just to talk to other agencies?
- Sharon Hurd
Person
It's an interagency health deal in RNs. We're doing a. We ask them to help us with the immediate. We're not going to do posters and print. We want. We want them to help us to send the message to people where they get their news. So they're going to do streaming.
- Sharon Hurd
Person
I think we said we're going to do 10,000. Was it? I'm sorry. I'm going to correct myself. 20,000.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Okay, so the 3.3 million was part of Act 231. 163 was part of Act 231846. Also 231 positions. We're asking them to move from a one year to mix.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Then the still with Act 231 we have the biosecurity program, compost reimbursement and green waste. We're asking for the same 1.2 million economic development specialist position. This was not 231. No. And it is for 63. And this is for someone to help us manage our grants. The micro grant for food security is a handful this year.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
The applications reduced from 7,000 applications to 2,000. But even that was difficult for the team to manage. And the supply chain for grants. As we know once you award a grant you have a contract to do. You have to certify it. And then in the ASO shop fiscal has to do invoices, checks, closeouts.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we're asking for this position to focus on the backside of grants for economic and thank you to the gov. And hopefully the Legislature will continue to Fund is one important position. The next one is the program specialist and funds for the farm to state and farm to food bank program.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We have been trying, you know, moving people around to support the farm to food bank because we know how important it is. So many people rely on the food bank. We know that the number one thing that people come looking for is poi and tarot.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And in order to supplement that, the 500,000 in here would be to get programs to increase production of the foods that they want. They lack produce, they have a lot of value add, they have a lot of frozen but they lack fresh produce and they lack point.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So the 500,000 that we're asking for program funds here is for not only a position, the 30 and 76,000 is for the position but the 500,000 is for programmatic. And we hope that can survive the conference. Okay, then we're going to just before this we canceled out the 150 that was. We're not going to go for that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Four motor vehicle replacement. Thank you for that. We really need that. There are some of our cars are over seven, you know, over 101517 years old. So thank you if you can maintain that for us. And then that is the extent of our ask.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
Going back to your biosecurity, I See, you have a number of projects and staffing, but how are you coordinating as a whole biosecurity strategy in terms of controlling when it comes in the ports or through airplanes or postal, and then controlling it once it's in? So it seems the two need to be coordinated.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
How is it aligned and working with, say, when you're coming in, working with the harbors and the airports and also with dle, I guess they're doing some enforcement. What are you doing in coordinating with all the agencies to protect us? Like, biosecurity is everybody's business.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Yes, it is. It is. I'm going to start with the Akamai Arrival program that we're rolling out the momentum with. The Akamai Arrival program is with the AG form that is currently by paper.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And I'm going to defer to the Lieutenant Governor's presentation on Thursday, because just before her presentation, she will be having a meeting with the airlines and she'll have an updated report. But it's good the airlines have stepped up, and the Akamai arrival is, to your point, is the entry.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And then we also have another electronic form that we're working on called hipop. It's for animals. The Animal Industry Division is tasked with taking away a family Member that arrives without the proper papers.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
If you come in with a dog or cat that you consider to be your family Member and they don't have the proper papers, it's really. It's a tough, tough decision to whether to stay. Okay.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And let your pets stay with the Animal Industry Division until the proper documents can be retrieved so that we can ensure that the biosecurity for the state is, you know, we don't have gravies that we're introducing. Public health and safety is preserved.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So the Akamai Arrival High Pop portal is going to be an electronic portal that they can fill in beforehand so they know what papers they have if they have all the different rabies tests and blood tests that they need, because it's been very difficult for the staff to have to tell somebody upon arrival that they don't have that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
You know, I think the. For instance, the AG form. So far, we've expended $7,000 for the soft software from which.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
Isaac Mehta for Animal Industry Division. I can only speak to the high pop because that's a dog and cat in our rabies quarantine branch that was funded through user fees. And we've actually already. The contractor is already engaged.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
They actually already built the platform and it's being limited use by certain pet owners at this point so that we can get a good read on it. So the dog and cat side of things, I can speak to that. That's been taken care of.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Senator, I'm going to call up Jonathan to answer where the 7000 for the AG form came from.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
Good afternoon. Chairs, Members of the Committee, Jonathan Ho, Plant Quarantine Branch Manager. So the branch has a salesforce based data collection system and we have a maintenance contract with the vendor who developed it. So we utilize the existing contract to develop the online portal portion for the Akamai arrivals.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
And that's the $7,000 was out of the Pest Inspection Eradication quarantine Fund, the S4 Fund.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So has the Department ever followed up on people who don't fill out the form? Because if it's the law, but where's the enforcement?
- Jonathan Ho
Person
That is the biggest challenge with the quarantine or the form in of itself. The statute does allow for a family, adult family Member to fill out for the entire family.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But if the Department doesn't start to make an example of people who don't do it, then no one's going to take it seriously.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But how do you enforce that? What's the enforcement plan on either form, the paper or the digital? What's the enforcement plan?
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So there's a couple of things. So one of the issues is the penalty is criminal.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And so who's checking and who's saying. Has every prosecuted anybody?
- Jonathan Ho
Person
We have not since the, since the statute was changed from civil to criminal. I believe in 2010 a criminal prosecution has not occurred for an agriculture declaration form. Prior to that we were issuing citations.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Those are civil, so we're not really getting accurate information. And then people are or either not filling out the form because we're not, we don't take it serious. So they may not take it serious.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
The. So with regards to the form and I think to speak to the need for increased compliance, one of the biggest challenges is the ability to administratively search people. Right. You know, like we the inspectors need.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Good cause, which I get that. But if you guys are having challenges, like Members have said before, then you should let us know what statutorily needs to be changed so then you can actually do enforcement. Because we're not with you at the airport. We're not, you know, we're not the one in charge. You guys have to implement.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And so if you find that you have Hurdles. You need to let us know what legislatively has to be changed so you can actually do the job. Because if we don't take biosecurity seriously, this is what's happening. We got coconut, rhinoceros beetle, little fire ant.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I mean the thing goes on and on and on and it's just getting worse.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So with regards to the digital form, we're trying to make it as flexible as possible to give as many opportunities for people to fill it out instead of being on the plane.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Yeah, but that's not my concern. My concern is where is the enforcement plan? Where is the compliance plan? Making it easier for people is fine, but who's going to enforce it?
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So the, the biggest thing with regards to passenger baggage and to. In to gaining additional compliance is essentially using detector dogs because that gives that, that overcomes. Are you asking for that or do you have the money for that? So one of the challenges is the facility, but still that's fine.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
What's the plan then? I mean, got to be a little more proactive and compliance and detection and we're depending on you. If not, we're just reacting to everything.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We are. This is not the first year that we've heard this and we are trying. We will come back with a plan. We will get together with plan.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
The governor's concern in vetoing the 20 million was he didn't think you could spend it all and maybe he wasn't convinced that you had a plan, so he vetoed.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So if you actually can show that you can spend the full amount and the results that we're going to get from it, then at least you can help justify it.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Jonathan, I think what we, what the Senator and the Committee is asking is that we come up with a plan. And dogs are expensive. Maintenance of dogs is very expensive. The trainers are expensive, the facility is expensive. But we will get you that number and how many we need. And you don't own the dogs, you rent them.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, but you know what? You guys are supposed to come up with plans and implementation. We will come up strategies and with the, with the budget that allows for it. That's the budget Director or the Governor to say we can't afford it or our job to say we can't afford it.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I don't know why you would limit yourself in putting down what you think is needed when your job is to effectuate the statutes.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Back to Senator Meraki's question. The biosecurity plan, besides the arrival portion which by the way includes boats and private planes and military. We're going to identify pathways money was provided. I think it was $240,000 for the risk assessment.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we decided after some discussion that the original plan was to do training of the staff, take them down to Amazon, show them the facility and say, hey, this is where you need to look at.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
But it's so big, we decided to RFP it and we're going to ask for a vendor to give us a report not only for the entry ports like Amazon or Pacific Air Cargo or private jets, FedEx, UPS, you know, the little holes that we have, but show us this is where your vulnerability is.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
This is where your biggest risk is. Send your people here operationally, you know, back of the door. This is where you should be or should you be a plane. So going to use that money for the risk assessment for the ports. Yeah. So that, that's where we're starting.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And then once they're and the vacancy. You know, we added positions and then, you know, we, we funded some positions with General Fund. I mean I put some of you in touch with Leigh Community College so that they could start doing a CTE pathway so that we can Fund some of these positions.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So when I had spoke to the governor's office when they were talking about vetoing, I, you know, I mentioned the fact that no, we, we can fill these positions if we work with Leeward on, on a CTE pathway. And Leeward was willing to work with you guys in doing the classes and the training at your facilities.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But you still are missing a compliance component, an enforcement component. That part if not no. Who's going to take it serious?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Understood. Follow up. Electronic. You just came back and is it in being instituted now? Electronic no.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Last year they said you were going to start with that's been expanded and on when the LG Lieutenant Governor Luke comes on Thursday, she'll have met with all the airlines and I believe we.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Anyway, I've been advised that many airlines are going to be participating instead of just the one or two. I think the Alaska Hawaiian merge, while a wonderful thing now limited to one airline. Now it's going to be more than just the one. They've expanded it.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So when is the want to I don't want to jinx it but by the, by the end of the fiscal.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Zero, that's my, that's I me that's me talking. But it's really the.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Point to who's going to read and translate what's on the computer and then follow through. Because that's the whole situation with the paper. Somebody picks it up, but nobody. They pick it up, and you never hear from them. You know, you write, I have a snake. Nobody calls you up, you know. Yeah, nobody calls you up.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
You put it in the thing and the bin goes. And. Yeah. So who's. You. You have the. You have a plan and the manpower and everything in place. So when June comes around, you guys have the personnel that's going to accept all the digital computer and read it and follow through.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I'm gonna say yes, because you don't need as many personnel right now. We have people that go to every plane and pick up the papers.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
Yeah. Because it goes through the baggage claim, it comes in an envelope, and then somebody.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Person gives it to somebody. Then again, I should defer to the lieutenant governor's briefing.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
But not every single airline is going to be doing it. So you're still going to have some people having to get the forms.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
Sorry. So I'm sorry. So one of the things specifically with the digital form is each of the airlines have their own proprietary systems. And trying to create something that can work for all of them has been a challenge. Okay. But you know what?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
We Fund the airport. Right. I mean, it comes to our budget. DOT has. They have the airports Committee. I mean, some of that should be, to some extent, an exchange. You want us to. To make the improvements at the airport, all the aesthetics. And you also have to help us with protecting Hawaii.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
And so it can't just be this silo where Department of AG is on the side and the airlines don't have to say do anything. We. We got to figure this out leveraging other branches.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I think biosecurity and interagency should come in the same biosecurity and interagency collaboration. I just need to confirm. I. I misspoke earlier, you know, about.
- Donna Kim
Legislator
So we're still slated for June, even though each airline have their own system. I don't know how you're going to coordinate on.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So it's not necessarily the system. I think it's. But the difference is going to be the way that they deliver the information. So the way that it's submitted is standardized. But how they're going to be rolling it out when they're going to be rolling it out.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
We're going to be working with each of the airlines and again, I think a pilot scan, pilot standpoint to kind of, they kind of know their, their system and if they're one airline has a better way of doing it, can utilize that.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
When you get into more standardized system in terms of, I think direct implementation as opposed to just collection, we're trying to open up collection, try to get as much people initially because it's a smaller, small number and we want to also manage.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
Have you worked with Department of Transportation? Are you working with them? Because there is an airlines Association so that you can actually look at what can you do systemically instead of airline by airline?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
No, I think going back to this, there's going to have to be legislation, which I know some of us are working on for biosecurity because this is. It needs to be ramped up. This side had questions.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
Yeah, thanks, Jerus. I. So assuming you do get the, the electronic form. I'm assuming that means the paper, the paper forms go away. We don't have to fill. No one has to fill those out anymore.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I'm going to defer to the lieutenant Governor, but that's my understanding.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
Okay, so, but, but if they, if people, if everybody's using some sort of electronic filing before they get on a plane, does that mean that if they, if they haven't filed the form that they don't get on the plane? You still get on the plane even if you haven't filed it, you'll have.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay, but they don't let you off the plane. If you don't, that's where. Then I agree.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
It's the airline's responsibility to capture that information. Then I agree.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Are you finding the airline? Are you guys finding. If it's their responsibility, then why aren't you guys getting on the airline saying, hey.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
So I think at this point I agree with Chair Della Cruz that if there's no backend enforcement, and at least in my experience there isn't. I mean, I think, I think I've literally gotten off planes and didn't pass the thing in because the. They never came around to collect it. So I don't go down.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
I don't go down. I very rarely check bags. So I never go downstairs. And, you know, so that it just, you just walk out of there and there's nothing to stop you from doing it. So that does seem like a major problem in terms of.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
Well, as number one thing I've learned is being sheriff's the Judiciary Committee for a long time, it's not the penalty that matters. It's whether you think you're going to get caught. And nobody thinks they're going to get caught in this situation.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So on. But on that note, you said it was civil before. Used to be. Used to be. So was that more effective than having it as a criminal penalty because you haven't been able to have any charges on the criminal side? Right.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
I know that people, we were, we were citing people. I, I mean, whether it was more effective or not. I, I don't have any, I guess what factual evidence to say one way or another.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Who determined that it was going to become criminal instead of civilization? Was that a legislative thing or. The Department asked.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
I'm just not sure who asked. Yeah. Where the idea originated. Was it you guys?
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
Zero, it was quite a while ago. Right. 2010 or something like that. Yeah.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
Carol was here back then. It was after the rift. So I, I, I don't know.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So I know that at that time that, that the, that was right after the economic downturn and the Legislature did increase the permitting fees and, and some of the Institute fees for inspections and some of the penalty, some of the, the fines that were tied to the criminal penalties were increased.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So I, I'm not sure if that was I think part of it as like partially deterrence and yeah.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So, but, but there has to be a lot of restructuring because I know when Department of Ag and I guess there was a group of us, we went to not Matt. Well, was it young brothers? Was it young brothers? And I asked a question there. Do you have a, they have a safety officer?
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So I asked do you have a biosecurity officer? And they said no. So I'm not sure why that Ports of entry Airlines, harbors. We don't have biosecurity officers at those companies. So that there is somebody to be in charge and make sure that there's compliance at least internally. And then we have, they can work with our agencies.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But if we don't make it a priority, they're not making it a priority. I mean these are things that we should require.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So I, I want to go back to the biosecurity unlike I try to follow the law and fill out my paperwork even though I'm not a judiciary. But it's a good thing you try. At least you know the biosecurity and I just don't say this. We always wait to buy Ants get out of control.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Where are we besides what you like call educating about Avian influenza and the voluntary program of you can volunteer whether or not to move a bird or not move a bird and how do you prevent that breakout after we just saw the first case of human death irregardless of underlying conditions in the meaning.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I will call on Dr. Mayetta if there's a further question regarding where we are on H5N1 nationally, it's a bigger problem than it is right now For Hawaii that's voluntary. 90 day stop movement has been effective in that.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I got an email from someone who was planning a trip in June and she has a household pet that she wants to transport from island to island. And so I'm just using that as an example of awareness that people are aware that there is a voluntary stop movement.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I told her that we would regroup In March, the 90 days ends March 13th. And cross your fingers that nothing outbreak or nothing, you know, happens.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Why do we cross our fingers and wait when you have a situation here, why not isolate the situation here in Honolulu so that you know more the spread of that and then you come back to us for more money to now clean up the mess that you could have done in the beginning.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, again I'm going to go with the interagency biosecurity. The migrating birds are, you know, they're everywhere. We don't know where they touch down. They could be in every forest or every island.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
All the more reason why since you have the case here, I would expect as the Director that would be a priority when you come in for the type of money that you guys are coming in. It's kind of like when I come in at the airport and I agree fully with you about the dogs.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
What I don't agree is when the dogs smelling my food in my bag because I'm not pretty sure when dogs know my food that if the dog ain't trained properly, you know, I would assume that somebody going reimburse me for that food because I don't like eat the food on the plane.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
A bit lucky that's not on the questionnaire. But how do you guys address biosecurity? We've been through this over and over. Coconut, rhinoceros beetle and now we're looking for all these funding. We're not in people to feel the vacancies to address that. And my understanding is you got two more vacancies in your Department.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So regarding H5N1, we've detected it in the water. We've detected it in a.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
We know where you detect it. I want to know what is the plan on prevention now and on mandatory of which you have people that are trying to sustain themselves as we double food production. We have all these egg layers that are now concerned if that reaches them.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Who handles if they got to kill all those chickens that laying eggs on islands that have contracted with some of these stores.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Maybe I should call. I will call up Dr. Maera. He has a response regarding the egg layers. They've been out there and they really have a comprehensive program.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
My only question before you even ask that, will you take on the burden of reimbursing if they got to kill out their entire flock of egg layers?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I don't. I'd have to check with the nationals, see how they're handling the reimbursement program. But I will take on the responsibility of checking with usda.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
I would rather you figure it out yourself because the last time you and I went to D.C. you had a hard time, even on the renewal of the permits of the bovine tuberculosis, that you failed to put some of the wild species that should have been tested upon bovine tuberculosis.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
Isaac Mehta Administrator, Animal Industry Division One of the things that you have to realize is that stopping the movement of birds, if they're not coming from an infected facility, since you have it already in the wild, is not going to be effective.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
That's why throughout the continental US where they've had even influenza for many years, since 2015 and before, what you do is kind of what we did with this instance where we detected it in that backyard flock, is you go in and you have to control it at that point now, because we've already found that even before it got into that, that backyard flock, they had, the wildlife services had tested a duck from North Shore.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
This was before everything, but we didn't get the results back until after we had already started our, you know, process at this backyard flock. But that actually was a November 1 sample that was positive already. So it was already in the wildlife.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
That's probably how it got into the flock that that particular person had, because there was intermixing of wild and, you know, basically the domestic fowl.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So, Dr. Mehra, that's my point. You guys know the intermixing is here?
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Why allow on transport to take place within the neighbor islands to put them at risk?
- Isaac Mehta
Person
Because the transporting of animals that are not sick, and the only way you're gonna guarantee they're not sick is you're gonna have to Institute animal certificates of veterinary inspection or why not?
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
You guys get a better handle on the situation. As a mandatory versus a voluntary. Today we might say, okay, I feel good jumping on this plane. I reach to the other side and I'm sick and I cough on everybody and infect everybody else.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
The only Way that, you know, we would actually be okay with something like that. Is there some kind of exemption for agriculture? Because right now you have hatcheries and you have brooders that move chickens, chicks, to different islands. Yeah, we're not talking game birds. We're not talking about those kinds of.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
I understand that this brought up the egg layers. Yeah, there's 2,000 egg layers right now. Yeah. And literally is sustaining over 50% of the egg population on Molokai.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
I mean, it's. You know, the other thing that I don't want people to get the misunderstanding of is the false security that you only got it on Oahu. It is not anyplace else. Because it's in the wildlife. Because the wildlife migrates from Alaska, California. They have ducks and what have you to fly over.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
We got seabirds that go back and forth. It's likely that's how it got introduced. But do we have a real good understanding of how many of these animals are infected? No, we don't. We only got that one sample.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So basically we just go into. If we get infected, then we come back and say, zero, by the way, now we got infection on the other islands. They're flocks. We have to put them all down. Is that what. I don't see.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
I don't see a way that you can say that the other islands do not have Avian influenza. We haven't detected it yet. But then again, there aren't any sampling going on. They had the H5 detection in Hilo. Right. So the biosecurity that the commercial flocks and backyard people do is really important because it's in the wildlife.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
They have to stop that commingling of wildlife and the commercial flock and people. All of that has to be done. But we just. We have a surveillance strategy, though. Surveillance. Yeah, we trying to do. What we do now is that we have a line where people call, and if it's something that looks like it's.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
We have to investigate, then we do sampling. Yeah, we're doing surveillance sampling.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay. Because when we went to New Zealand, they have a very strong and robust surveillance program. And we have different FFA classes or clubs. We got ag schools, we got all kinds. Why aren't we incorporating them to help us as even volunteers to help do surveillance on every island?
- Isaac Mehta
Person
We would like to. We would like to get some other agencies actually involved in this, especially with wildlife. Because, you know, we're agriculture and we do domestic. That's what I'm Talking about ffa. Right, but you have a biosecurity in their curriculum. Incorporate them as part of the.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
Sure, we can do that, but we need to get really a handle on what's happening out there in the wildlife. Right, because you already saw we got one in Kahuku.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Do we have any more on the island? But like you said, how many people are going to go through the forest and go figure this out? No, but if we can at least get what the different farms where people can know what to look for, they can report it in addition to what you're talking about.
- Isaac Mehta
Person
No, the farms are doing that. We have outreach to the farms. There's some farms, there's two of them on the island that are actually what's called Natural Poultry Improvement Program. And so they actually routinely do testing even though they don't see anything in their flock. Yeah, so there's this kind of stuff going on too.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But even in the case of little fire ants or coconut rhinoceros beetle, we don't necessarily have a proactive surveillance plan. You know when. And maybe Carol can explain it to you. zero, he knows. You know, they put a boundary around a certain area. Once something is detected and the whole community almost. Yeah.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Looks like goes out, they look at different signs, they report it back, and then they can figure out, okay, is it in this area or not? And if it's not, then they let the farms go back to normal operating. If it is, then they try to contain it.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But we're not being a lot more proactive the way we should be. We do do surveillance for other types of viruses too, like, we do. And I'm not just talking that. I'm talking about some like coconut, rhinoceros beetle, little fire ant, which is maybe not your Kuleana, but. Yeah, we still need a surveillance program.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Right now we're on the public properties that we detect CRB. We have access to this tape, let's say it's a park or a beach. And we know that that has been treated systemically.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And of course, if it's treated systemically, you don't want to be eating the coconuts for about a year because it could affect the coconut, the person eating it could be allergic. So we, we've been giving out tape, this yellow tape that says do not eat. We've given up quite a few. We've just.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
That goes back to what we talked about earlier. You know what, the General public, they don't know that. So you got to go back to. The public awareness campaign.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, it does say do not eat and there's a date and time. So I mean that's a proactive effort.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
We tell people you got to fill out the form for the AG form. Do they do it? No.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I have a question different related on your table 15 for your CIP, so for your animal quarantine facility you have 6 million. That's for planning and design. So that's going to be DOA's responsibility rather than DCRS.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
That's actually for tar removal. That was detected quite some time ago and before you know, it got funded this year. Thank you very much for adding it to the budget. But it's this tar that's been seeping up in the ground. We just don't know what.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So it has nothing to do with planning design for relocation.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
It has nothing to do with, you know. But you make a very good point, Senator, that we realize we need to start labeling these projects for the lava jail.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
That maybe it starts off with jail because it's getting confused that the first, you know, we have several projects at the Halawa animal industry that have nothing to do with the jail but it seems to be overlooked because it's an expense that maybe is not a popular one. Really though it's not for the jail.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
So we're coming up with a system where we'll say jail, you know, and then the other one would be Halava because this one is tar removal.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
So we had the Committee, other committees, Ways and Means and Public Safety had a similar briefing this afternoon and we talked a lot about fireworks.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
It would appear that you and the and the people who are trying to catch the illegal fireworks have a similar kind of problem in that you're trying to keep something from coming into the state. Have you talked to them, have you talked to the Department of Law Enforcement about how you might be able to coordinate efforts?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Actually, yes. The DLE has taken the lead on ag crime. They actually have a pilot program where they.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, egg crime, we're considering it as biosecurity because part of the incoming, the trespass spreads diseases. They're actually going up there for hunting a lot of the trespasses for it's all kind of interagency intermingle trespasses, a lot of times for stealing of fruit.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
But in terms of security at the ports and airports, that's the Part I was interested in.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
All right. Right now the daily is not doing biosecurity at the ports. They're handling biosecurity outside of the ports. For us, we don't, you know, we, we look for the same thing, but we have a kind of a sort of advantage because the things that we look for come in on a manifest. Yes.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
We just found another possum on Hilo. So the, the creatures that come in.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Are not like fireworks, you know, like they move around, they scurry.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
Well, the question I really had was, so they're. They're going to be scanning. I mean, if they.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
It seems to me like there's a possible synergy before with the, the types of scanners they're talking about buying, which are quite expensive, and looking for stuff that they're interested in, but also possibly looking for stuff that you're interested in or the. Or the dog. I guess you can cross train dogs too, to sniff different things.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
It just feels like there's. You're doing sort of the same kind of thing. And I hate to just buy everything twice.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
Yeah. So. So I guess one of the. So I guess one of the differences is, is that as chair heard said, a lot of the inspections are. Are based off of specific, basically classes of commodities that require inspection. And we work with the transportation companies to provide those things to us for inspection prior to release.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
And with regards to, I guess, like contraband generally, because the goods that we're looking at aren't contraband. Right. So during the course of the inspection, because we have administrative search authority, basically we can open with good cause, whereas, you know, DLE cannot do that. Right. Any warrants to do that type of stuff.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
And you know, obviously the use of a machine can provide that type of ability to gain a warrant. But during the course of the inspection, staff have. Have found contraband drugs and things like that. And obviously we do refer them to their appropriate authorities.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
And I think from the standpoint of synergy moving forward with regards to like DLE or I guess other agencies who don't necessarily do agricultural goods, collaboration is something we do. Like, we currently work with customs and usda.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
We usda, we do joint operations for federal stuff where we have no authority and they do stuff with us for domestic stuff in which they have no authority.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
So from the Department standpoint, working with other regulatory agencies to find ways to bridge those gaps so that there isn't a duplication of effort, like it's a call, hey, we did. We've discovered a tree or an insect, then you know, we can respond and utilize our authority. And likewise, ideally we found fireworks. Leave it open.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
They can do what they need to do. I don't think there's an expectation to duplicate limited resources when you can do one scan and essentially find a lot of different things for various agencies.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
We talked about that at the, in the previous one and they just, they just got to figure out how much it's going to cost and what, what would the scanner actually cost us then? They don't know what it is yet. But they're willing, sounds like they're willing to help.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
But do you need the technology, you need the equipment and so they have to start doing some cost estimates on for some of that and then you're going to need staff to mean to manage it.
- Jonathan Ho
Person
Customs and Border Protection does utilize some types of mobile scanners for things. My understanding is the scanning process is very timely from the standpoint of trying to manage volume against the actual scan. So I think, well, I think they're, they're very good for like spot checking to some extent, you know, with, you know.
- Karl Rhoads
Legislator
Yes, I think they, I think daily needs reasonable suspicion too. It's not the border where you can just open everything, right? No, that's why you need the scan. So the scan. So once you have reasonable suspicion then you can scan it. But then why not look for both at that point? Yeah. Okay.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
The pesticide take back program you guys initiated, I had a question that when you guys took back the pesticides and I brought that up with you folks, that why wasn't the people managing the pesticide take back giving out amounts of consumption on take back within paperwork form off of your letterhead to say I just received from so and so's farm or ranch, 50 gallons, 25 gallons of restricted use so that they can balance out their books when they come in for inspection by your restricted use pesticide branch.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
For that Greg, as I said, he woke up sick this morning. So he's the manager of the pesticide branch.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Yeah, but I asked you this three months ago and you said you were going to follow up with that. So I've had the same request by these farmers that took in and other people that they inherited on farm and they gave back their restricted use pesticide.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
What they wanting is to make sure the inventory matches when they drop off the restricted use as not to have sold it or dumped it in on river. So what they're wanting is that paper, it said that farmer, that individual dropped off two and a half gallons of RUPs and that your division signs off on it.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
It was right in my office with your pesticide branch. Okay. Sounds like an info briefing for the Committee on Ag and Environment.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
I was. Senator. I'm sorry, I'll follow up. In fact, I think they do walk away with a record of what they dropped off. Absolutely nothing. They don't. Okay. Sorry. See, Greg? See what happens when you don't show up?
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
I'm going to change subjects. What's happening with Act 90, the transfer of lands from DLNR to AG or AG and where. What's the status of it?
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Brian is here. Did you bring any notes on Act 90? Okay. Act 9 is doing well. You're working very well together with DLNR. So where are we? What's.
- Frankel Ag
Person
Frankel Ag, Research Management Administrator. Let's see. Since January 12023 we've transferred 22 parcels totaling 5,500 acres from DLNR. We are still working with DLNR. Well, you know, the number might have gone up a little bit. I don't know if I was able to check.
- Frankel Ag
Person
Unfortunately, we are still working with DAR and trying to decide how. Never going to happen. Sorry, sir. We're. We're. We don't want to make it.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
What's awkward though, I still. Is it. It doesn't. The ownership doesn't transfer to you, just the management.
- Frankel Ag
Person
Yeah, the ownership always has always restayed with the line division.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Okay. That's where I'm still. I'm. But just so. But don't you still need Land Board approval at some point?
- Frankel Ag
Person
No, no, we don't. Once the. So the. The fee, the title fee of the parcel does remain State of Hawaii, which is ultimately controlled by the Land Division. So if. If there were to be any deed transactions on the land that would have to go and be done through Land Division, the Department of Agriculture. Yeah.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
So let's say a farmer wanted to, you know, help build processing. Would that have to go Land board or just you?
- Frankel Ag
Person
Just us. As long as it's within our rules or. Yeah. Statutes and rules. We would The Department of Agriculture, the Board of Agriculture would be able to approve them. So it's only so they have no saying once, once they get transferred. Correct, Correct.
- Frankel Ag
Person
As long as it's as long as the purpose for which the ask is is within the scope of the original Executive order.
- Frankel Ag
Person
Then what it stays with us it in as long and to be relet under the conditions of the program. Okay, we don't, we don't have to go to back to BOA.
- Donovan Dela Cruz
Legislator
Sorry. Bonr. I'm just not sure why just the title is not just transferred to adc. That I can't tell you. Because in that way it's just ag. And then you could still manage it. I mean it's the same arrangement that you have with dlnr.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
One last question. Since you're there. What is the status of the $2 million? This is really actually Senator Dacoit, but the Molokai irrigation system we gave you 2 million last time and now you're asking for another 5 million 2.7 and 2.7 million for fiscal year 2627. What's the status of that?
- Frankel Ag
Person
I think I left it on my phone at the chair but I believe. Well, we have not spent well, we don't intend on lapsing any of the appropriated funds that have been granted to us for which includes the previous Molokai funds as well.
- Frankel Ag
Person
If I recall correctly, it was to do things like joint coupling repairs for some blow offs that had happened along the access road and a few things other smaller things at the base yard, I believe it was. But yeah, these things, you know these pipes are huge. They're like, you know what 40 something, 70 something inches.
- Frankel Ag
Person
They're really really big. So they're, you know, just changing one coupling is not a simple task.
- Frankel Ag
Person
We were only able to do some of them. We had to cut scope back when we put out the CIP project because we didn't have enough money to go.
- Frankel Ag
Person
If again if I recall correctly, it is to complete the replacement of all of these joint couplings within the pipeline for the from the reservoir and I don't recall if there are a few base yard improvements. There may be also something else for data management.
- Sharon Moriwaki
Legislator
So what is the total project that you want to do and what is the total cost and what will it give us?
- Frankel Ag
Person
So the best of my knowledge, it's this is going to complete what this ask is for. It's about I believe right around $5 million. Now these are. I don't mean to go on about this, but you know the systems do age.
- Frankel Ag
Person
So it, it will not be the last ask for MIS or any of our other irrigation systems. Like any kind of utility, they do require maintenance and, and replacement and modernization over time.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
A quick follow up. So based on that, you know, I know that you guys past meetings on your agenda has been on water rate increase right across the board. But then I think your last three Board Meetings were canceled because the response was you guys had nothing to discuss.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So I want to know why didn't you try to figure out without doing a lottery increase, prioritizing on requests on budget for the offset of the water increase to Fund operations? No, I think she's talking about the water rate increases. Since we're talking about the reservoir system.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Why is it that you haven't requested as a priority for us to put in for operational? Isn't that why you're asking to do a water rate increase right across the board on the farmers?
- Frankel Ag
Person
Zero, I see. Okay. So we actually it is something that we have been discussing for the past couple of years.
- Frankel Ag
Person
One of the asks that we had put in, I believe it was last year, was to remove some of the positions on the revolving Fund, which is the Fund that collects the revenue for the delivery fees, to move some of those positions over into the General Fund.
- Frankel Ag
Person
And what that will do is obviously is create some space for us to allow the purchase of new vehicles, slope mowers and equipment such as possibly even like a clear the tunnel when it rains hard, things like that.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
No, no. But you're doing one water rate increase statewide, right?
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Right across the board. So if you looked at that and you were trying to, you guys were trying to come up with that amount, right? To handle your operational costs. Why wasn't the operational cost that you guys are going to inflict on the water users statewide on water rate increase put in as a priority request.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
I'm not sure I'm addressing that question. But the watery increase you guys are asking what was your reasoning why you.
- Frankel Ag
Person
Guys want a lottery increased to account for the increase in costs for us to maintain operate and maintain the statewide systems which would total like believe right now it we're looking at somewhere around the neighborhood of. I had to if my memory recall it's around 2 million.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So why would that not be on request of your guys? Ask in your budget versus putting the the burden on farmers that are already struggling well on water rate increase. At this point you're not asking for that water. It's been tabled for now.
Bill Not Specified at this Time Code
Next bill discussion: January 7, 2025
Previous bill discussion: January 7, 2025