Hearings

Senate Floor

January 23, 2025
  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    Will the joint session of the 33rd Legislature please come to order? Before proceeding, the Legislature would like to recognize some of the distinguished guests joining us today. And on Tuesday when I watched the Speaker read the long list of distinguished guests, I realized today I'm going to ask Senate Clerk Carol Taniguchi to please read the list of distinguished guests that are here today. Because I can see well far, but I cannot read close without my glasses. Thank you, Madam Clerk.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Governor Josh Green and First Lady Jamie Green.

  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    Madam Clerk. So I already messed up my part of the script. And as the Clerk introduced our honored guests so that we could get to the Chief Justice's speech, would you please hold your applause until all of our guests have been introduced.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Lieutenant Governor Sylvia Luke and second Gentleman Michael Luke. Chief Justice Recktenwald's son, Andrew Recktenwald and brother in law Joseph Mahoe. Former First Lady Jean Ariyoshi, former Governor John D. Waiheʻe III and Mrs. Lynne Waiheʻe. Former Governor Ben Cayetano and Mrs. Vicky Cayetano.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Members of the Hawaii Supreme Court, Associate Justice Sabrina McKenna, Associate Justice Todd Eddins, Associate Justice Lisa Ginoza, Associate Justice Vladimir Devens. Former Associate Justice Paula Nakayama, former Associate Justice Michael Wilson, former Associate Justice Richard Pollack and Mrs. Candy Pollack, former Associate Justice Simeon Acoba and Mrs. Carolyn Acoba, former Associate Justice James Duffy Jr. U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals Senior Judge Richard Clifton, U.S. District Court Senior Judge Helen Gillmor, U.S. District Court Judge J. Michael Seabright, U.S. District Court Chief Magistrate Judge Kenneth Mansfield.

  • Committee Secretary

    Person

    Acting U.S. Attorney Ken Sorenson, and members of the law enforcement community, including the County Chiefs of Police and prosecuting attorneys. From the County of Maui, Mayor Rick Bissen, Administrative Director of the Courts Rod Maile and Deputy Administrative Director of the Courts Daylin-Rose Heather. And former Deputy Director of the Courts and current Head of the Judiciary's Policy and Planning Department, Brandon Kimura.

  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    Please join me in a round of applause for our distinguished guests. The Chair hereby appoints the following legislators to escort the Honorable Mark E. Recktenwald, Chief Justice of the Hawaii Supreme Court, to the rostrum, on behalf of the Senate, Senator Rhoads and Senator Kanuha, on behalf of the House, Representative Tarnas and Representative Matsumoto. It It's.

  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    The Chair hereby requests the following legislators to present a lei to the Chief Justice. On behalf of the Senate, Senator Lynn DeCoite, and on behalf of the House, Representative Dee Morikawa.

  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    Now, I know you're all here to listen to the Chief Justice, and normally I'd simply introduce him so he could begin. But I know you're all aware that this is his last address as Chief Justice to deliver the state of the judiciary. And I would like to say, In September of 2010, when I was appointed to the Hawaii State Senate, I had the privilege of being sworn in by the Chief Justice. And every other time that I've stood here on opening day, he's administered the oath of office for me.

  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    And it's been a real pleasure to work with the Chief Justice over the last 15 years. He's been incredibly innovative, creative, compassionate, and has certainly been an outstanding manager as each of us in leadership had to be navigating through Covid, through security issues that we have faced. And his service to our state has been tremendous.

  • Ron Kouchi

    Legislator

    He will be missed, and I am so blessed to have had a great friend. Now, I was trying to get a quote for you, CJ, but between my opening day speech and the governor's State of the State, I'm all out of quotes. But my Chief of Staff, Harrison Kawate, shared with me this morning. One of our favorite movies is Tombstone. And as Wyatt Earp is riding off with his posse to take care of all those bad guys in the world, we wanted to take a line from Tombstone as a lead into your introduction. This is the last charge of CJ Recktenwald and his band of immortals. CJ.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Wow, chicken skin, huh? Mahalo to the staff and participants of Women's Court for sharing that beautiful oli with us. Women's Court is also known as Mohala Wahine, which means blossoming woman. And I can't think of a more fitting name to describe the growth and transformation of these women or a more meaningful way to start this morning.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    President Kouchi, Speaker Nakamura, Governor Green and First Lady Jamie Green, Lieutenant Governor Luke and Second Gentleman Michael Luke, Members of the Senate and House, former First Lady Jean Ariyoshi, former Governor John Waiheʻe and Lynne Waiheʻe, former Governor Ben Cayetano and Vicky Cayetano, Mayor Rick Bissen, Members of the Consular Corps, and the Royal Order of Kamehameha.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Distinguished guests, family, and friends, good morning and aloha. President Kouchi, mahalo for your support over the years. And Speaker Nakamura, we're excited to work with you in your new role. Later this year, I will reach the mandatory retirement age of 70. Today will be my eighth and last opportunity to formally address the Legislature since my appointment in 2010. I reflect back on my journey to this moment with humility, gratitude, and amazement.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    As a child growing up in Chicago, never in my wildest dreams did I imagine that one day I would have the honor and privilege of serving as Hawaii's Chief Justice. When I first arrived in Hawaii in 1980, I didn't know a soul. I carried my resume around this building and found my first job here working as a Committee Clerk. The person who decided to give me a chance was Senator Ann Kobayashi, and I'm forever grateful to her. I developed a deep respect for the Legislature, a respect that continues to this day.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    So standing here in this place, at this time is truly a full circle moment. I deeply appreciate the support of the Legislature for our efforts to make the judiciary more responsive to the needs of Hawaii's people. I'm excited to report that we'll be opening the new Wahiawa District Court next year. Mahalo to Senator Donovan Dela Cruz and Representative Kyle Yamashita for their support. This session, we've identified some important additional needs in our legislative package.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    These include funds to design a new courthouse in Waimea, to add a much needed district court judge in Kona, and to address a critical shortage of court appointed counsel in criminal and termination of parental rights cases. We've come a long way since 2010. Back then, our access to justice movement was just getting off the ground.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Today, we're recognized as one of the top states in the nation. Back then, there was no veterans court, environmental court, or women's court. Today, those programs are flourishing. Back then, the people of West Hawaii appeared in court at repurposed buildings scattered along the coast. Today, our new Kona courthouse is a vibrant hub dispensing justice.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    And back then, only about 30% of our full time judges were women. Today, exactly half of our judges are women. I'd like to review what the judiciary, with the support of the Legislature and our community partners, has accomplished and how we can build on it for the future. I'm going to talk about four broad areas.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Delivering critical services, enhancing access to justice, innovating for evolving needs, and promoting trust and confidence in the courts. First, I'm proud of how we've performed our core mission of deciding cases fairly and efficiently in accordance with the law.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    In any given year, our trial courts resolve more than 30,000 criminal cases, more than 18,000 civil cases, more than 13,000 family court cases, and hundreds of thousands of traffic and parking cases. We've made civil litigation more efficient by streamlining discovery and setting cases for trial sooner.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    We've doubled down on our commitment to alternative dispute resolution. Thanks to the Legislature, with Speaker Nakamura, Senator Troy Hashimoto, and others in the forefront, we implemented a pilot program for mediating landlord tenant disputes during the pandemic. It treated landlords fairly and helped people reach agreements that allowed them to stay in their homes.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    We're grateful to the Legislature for adopting a similar program from Maui last session. But the true test of an institution is how it steps up in times of crisis. The pandemic and the Maui fire severely tested our limits to respond and adapt, and we answered the call and met the challenge.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    During the pandemic, our judges and staff embraced remote proceedings so courts could continue to provide justice. Since then, we've held over 800,000 remote proceedings, an astonishing transformation of how we do business, which has made our courts more accessible. Another example of the resilience of the judiciary is the response to the Maui wildfires.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I'll never forget calling Judge Peter Cahill the next morning. I suspected he might ask me to temporarily close the courts on Maui, but instead he told me he was selecting a jury for a criminal trial. Potential jurors had shown up that day, even in the midst of an unspeakable tragedy that claimed the lives of 102 people.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Judge Cahill set the tone for our response. We would provide justice without interruption to a community that desperately needed stability, while extending grace and support to those who were impacted. Our Maui judges and staff, including employees who returned to work even though they lost their own homes, made all that happen.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    In the aftermath of the fires, people were desperate. They needed help on legal issues, from housing to immigration, and many of them simply needed someone to listen. Members of the Maui County Bar Association, including some who lost their own homes, stepped up big time to provide assistance in locations across Lahaina.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I was there, I saw them, and I've never been prouder. Others rose to meet the moment. Almost 300 attorneys from across the state staffed the hotline set up by the Hawaii State Bar Association. And our community's legal services providers joined in on the front lines.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Mahalo to Governor Green and Mayor Bissen for their leadership during those difficult times. Can you please join me in acknowledging all of them? Second, access to justice. I'm proud of how our legal community has come together to deliver on the promise of access to justice for all.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Each year, thousands of people in Hawaii have to represent themselves in civil cases because they can't afford an attorney. Those cases can involve issues as profound as whether a family will be evicted from their home or who will have custody of the children in a divorce. Our Access to Justice Commission has been a game changer.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    One of its signature initiatives is the self help centers in our courthouses where volunteer attorneys provide legal advice and information to people who don't have a lawyer, helping them present their side of the story in court. I'm grateful to the hundreds of volunteer attorneys and the Legal Aid Society of Hawaii for supporting this amazing effort.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    We now have centers across the state which have assisted nearly 39,000 people at almost no cost to the state. But we still don't have enough attorneys to meet the need, so we begun to consider how other highly trained professionals can help. Last year, the Supreme Court established a pilot project in Hilo, where Legal Aid paralegals working under the supervision of licensed attorneys represent clients in paternity cases. The vast majority of people in these cases are without counsel, even though momentous issues like child custody can be at stake.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Mahalo to Judge Darien Nagata and Legal Aid for getting this pilot off to a great start. We are using every resource at our disposal to get people the help they need. We launched a pro bono program for cases on appeal, supported the development of an online pro bono service, established a partnership with the state library system to make interactive court forums available at libraries across the state, train trusted community leaders about available legal resources, and placed volunteer court navigators in Maui District Court.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    The trust and collaboration that's been built through these efforts was on display in Waimānalo two weeks ago, when more than 40 volunteers from 10 different organizations came together for an expungement and bench warrant recall clinic. You could just feel the positive energy in the room, and those who were helped left with a weight lifted off their shoulders.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Thank you to Deputy Chief Judge Melanie May and Deputy Public Defender Eddie Aquino for their leadership. Mahalo also to Representative Lisa Marten for getting the word out and to Representative David Tarnas for his efforts on this issue. The future for access to justice is bright. There are promising opportunities to leverage artificial intelligence to enhance access.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Legal Aid recently rolled out an online AI powered legal navigator program, and we're actively assessing how the courts and legal profession can responsibly utilize AI to better serve the public. I thank Justice Vlad Devens and Judge Jack Tonaki for co-chairing this important work.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    All of these efforts have been noticed nationally. In the most recent Justice Index Survey, Hawaii ranked sixth among the states for our efforts to increase access to justice. We still have much work to do, but we can rightly be proud of how far we have come.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Third, innovation. I'm proud of how we've developed a culture of innovation at the judiciary. Let me share a few shining examples. First, we've learned that the pathways into the criminal justice system for women are different than men. Almost all of them have histories of trauma and abuse early in life. Shouldn't we account for those factors to help them heal and make better choices going forward? The answer is an emphatic yes. It started with Girls Court, where Judge Karen Radius founded a first of its kind court focused on the needs of teenage girls.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Girls Court assembles an all female team to work with them to nurture their strengths, build healthy relationships, and develop a sense of self worth and hope. More than 180 young women have completed the program, which just celebrated its 20th anniversary under the leadership of Judge Dyan Medeiros. We built on the spectacular success of Girls Court. In 2022, based on a proposal by Chief Judge Mark Browning and with the critical support of the Women's Legislative Caucus and in particular Representative Linda Ichiyama, the Legislature authorized a similar pilot program for adult women.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Women's Court has made incredible strides since then thanks to the stewardship of Judge Trish Morikawa and a great team of staff and partners at the prosecuting attorneys and public defenders offices. We can't afford to lose this momentum, so I'm asking the Legislature to make that program permanent this session. We can still do better.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Judge Morikawa is leading the Women's Corrections Implementation Commission to guide these efforts, and we've had strong support from a grassroots group that has come together, the Women's Prison Project. They've undertaken initiatives from opening transitional housing to building a fitness room at the Women's Correctional Center. Mahalo to former Governor Linda Lingle for her leadership of those efforts.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    You heard the beautiful voices of Mohala Wahine at the start of this program. I'd like to ask them, along with those who've been at the forefront of these crucial efforts, Judges Morikawa and Medeiros, retired Judge Radius, the amazing Women's and Girls Court teams, the Members of the Commission, and the Women's Prison Project to please stand and be recognized.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Girls Court and Women's Court are examples of treatment courts, a model that uses a team approach to address populations with specific underlying needs. We created a Driving While Impaired Court in 2013, which has reduced recidivism among some of the most dangerous drivers on our roadways. We created a Veterans Treatment Court that serves veterans who are having a hard time re-acclimating to civilian life. In 2017, our Community Outreach Court was created to help people who are unhoused find jobs and a stable place to live.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Many are held back by unpaid fines and fees, outstanding bench warrants, or the loss of their driver's license. Participants can work off their obligations through community service and get connected with resources that offer them a fresh start. Community Outreach Court meets people where they live. The court convenes in locations across across Oahu, from Waianae to Kaneohe, at community centers and public libraries. Sometimes a judge is seated across a picnic table from the participants, learning how they're doing and what they need to progress.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Community Outreach Court has resolved nearly 11,000 cases, recalled close to 900 bench warrants, lifted more than 7,000 license stoppers, and provided assistance to well over 600 participants. And those are remarkable results. Mahalo to our partners from the Honolulu Prosecuting Attorneys and Public Defender's offices.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Thanks to Judges Tom Haia, Shellie Park-Hoapili, and the late Darolyn Lendio Heim for making a difference in the lives of the participants. Every day our district courts see individuals with serious mental illness who have been picked up on nonviolent petty misdemeanors.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Working with the prosecutors and public defenders, we've developed new pathways to divert these offenders away from the justice system and into community based treatment. And last year, thanks to the leadership of Governor Green and with the support of Mayor Rick Blangiardi, a critical milestone was achieved.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    The state opened a drop off center in Iwilei where police can bring individuals in crisis to be stabilized and then offered services rather than arresting them. Make no mistake, all of these efforts are focused on making our community safer and there are guardrails in place to ensure that dangerous offenders are held in custody.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Developing the right tools for this work has taken years and is still evolving. We're grateful for the many legislators who've worked hard on these efforts, including Senator Karl Rhoads, Representative Della Au Belatti, Senator Joy San Buenaventura, Senator Sharon Moriwaki, among others. Thank you to each of them.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    On opening day, President Kouchi and Speaker Nakamura both spoke eloquently about the importance of education in ensuring a good future for our keiki. We couldn't agree more, but if kids aren't attending school, they'll miss out on that future. In 2015, we launched Truancy Court to address the challenges presented by chronic absenteeism. The key is early intervention so we can determine why kids are missing school and remove obstacles to regular attendance. The reasons can be as basic as lack of transportation or appropriate clothing, or a family's need for child care.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Truancy Court, which began at Waianae Intermediate School, has grown to serve four schools on Oahu, helping over 200 students last year, with most situations resolving without a formal court petition in 2022, we started the Early Education Intervention Program to reach elementary school students as well, with an additional 305 students at 27 schools on Oahu assisted this past year.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    We have an incredibly productive partnership with the Department of Education. Superintendent Hayashi is here. I really appreciate their support. Department of the Attorney General, Attorney General Anne Lopez is here. Again, we appreciate that office's support allowing us to establish similar programs across the state.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I'm grateful to Judges Dyan Medeiros , Rebecca Copeland, Jessi Hall, Natasha Shaw, Darien Nagata, and Gregory Meyers and all the program staff for their efforts. We've done all of this with existing resources, but we could do so much more with a modest investment.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    That's why we're seeking funding for three additional social worker positions here on Oahu to expand this work so our kids stay in school and can thrive. Fourth and finally, I'd like to focus on the single biggest challenge facing the judiciary, promoting public trust and confidence in the courts.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Surveys conducted by the Pew Center show that public confidence in government generally is at an all time low. We can't just assume we have the public's trust, we need to earn it. We started by making ourselves more transparent so the public can see who we are and what we do.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    The Supreme Court now livestreams our oral arguments, more than 125 times since 2020. Our move to remote proceedings means that many of our court hearings can now be viewed online, and with the implementation of electronic filing for all courts, the public can now more easily access court records.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Critically, we've also gone out into the community to engage directly with people, especially young people. Through our Courts in the Community Program, the Hawaii Supreme Court has held oral arguments in actual cases at high schools across the state. We've been in packed gyms from Kealakehe to Lahainaluna to Waianae.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Just last month, we convened before nearly 400 students students at Mililani High School to hear the case of a woman who'd been evicted from public housing. Volunteer attorneys visit the schools beforehand to help teach the students about the case, and afterwards the justices answer questions posed by the students. More than 6,000 students have attended these events, leaving with a better understanding of the judiciary's role in our democracy. To further enhance civic education, the court established the PACE Commission.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Under the leadership of Justice Lisa Ginoza and Representative Amy Perruso, the commission has conducted three day law and justice academies for high school students on Maui and in Hilo. Plans are underway for a similar academy on Kauai, and they've also worked to establish Schools for Democracy to recognize those schools whose efforts are really exceptional in this area.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    How else do we build trust in the courts? Trust is built by ensuring judicial Independence, which is critical to protecting the rule of law. Judicial Independence means that judges are able to decide cases impartially, free from passion, pressure, or outside influence. Only then can we expect the public to have confidence and trust in our decisions.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Trust is also built by acting with respect and aloha in the way we handle cases and how we treat people. One prime example is committing to respect Ōlelo Hawai'i. We establish that any party who wishes to communicate with the court in the Hawaiian language may do so. Mahalo to the Legislature, and in particular Senator Rhoads, who has provided vital resources to the judiciary's Hawaiian language program. Finally, trust in the courts is built by having capable judges who reflect the community we serve. Hawaii has a merit based system of judicial selection and retention.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I believe this system, which promotes both judicial Independence and accountability, is the best one available. It provides what people rightfully expect, highly qualified judges who decide based on the law and the facts of each case. One important responsibility I have as Chief Justice is to appoint the judges for our district and family courts, subject to Senate confirmation.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Over the years, I've appointed 61 new judges who now make up the majority of our full time judges. I always look for the most qualified candidate who's demonstrated a commitment to public service and have selected people from both prosecutor and public defender backgrounds, civil practitioners, government attorneys, and family law specialists, with 54% of them having been women.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    As I prepare to pass the torch to the next generation of judiciary leaders, I'm pleased to report the judiciary is strong, resilient, and thriving. As I look out into the audience, I see the faces of members of the judiciary who have worked tirelessly for many years to overcome difficult challenges. And I see new faces who are stepping up to join the fray. I'm filled with pride for our judges, administrators, and staff. And I'm confident in the judiciary's future. I know I'll be leaving our courts in good hands. Thank you for all that each of you do.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Could all of our judiciary ohana, justices, judges, administrators, and staff please stand to be recognized? Being here today, I'm reminded of my dear friend Pat Mau-Shimizu, who served as Chief Clerk of the House for many years, and I can feel her presence with us.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    She, more than anyone, would know that events like this require a tremendous amount of preparation. And I'd like to thank the amazing staff of the Senate and House, Clerks, and Sergeant of Arms offices for all their assistance today. Can you please join me in acknowledging them?

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I also remember fondly the outstanding legislators I worked with over the years as Chief Justice who have since passed away, including Representatives Mark Nakashima, Mark Takei, Clift Tsuji, Mele Carroll, and Senators Breene Harimoto, Gil Kahele, and Sam Slom.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    As I look back on the improbable path that's led me here today, I'm filled with gratitude for everyone who's helped me and supported the judiciary along the way. I want to thank Governor Lingle for her nominations that allowed me to join the bench and eventually become Chief Justice, and to the Senate for confirming me.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I've had wonderful mentors since becoming a judge, in particular Chief Judge Jim Burns and Chief Justice Ronald Moon, both of whom have left us and I miss them dearly. I'm grateful for all my colleagues at the Supreme Court. We're entrusted with the awesome responsibility of interpreting the Hawaii Constitution.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    We undertake our work with humility, with deep respect, and are always mindful our decisions profoundly affect people's lives. I've also had the privilege of working with many outstanding Chief Judges and Deputy Chief Judges and court administrators who set the bar high and led by example.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I'm grateful for the wonderful partners in the community who provided steadfast support for the judiciary, from Deans Avi Soifer and Camille Nelson at the William S. Richardson School of Law, to Larry Okinaga at the American Judicature Society, to the late Pat Mau-Shimizu and Cathy Betts at the Hawaii State Bar Association, to Randy Perera and Kalani Werner at UPW and HGEA, to Dan Foley, Simeon Acoba, and Joe Cardoza at the Access to Justice Commission, to Bob LeClair at the Hawaii Justice Foundation, and the staff and boards of the Legal Aid Society of Hawaii, Volunteer Legal Services Hawaii, the Native Hawaiian Legal Corporation, Domestic Violence Action Center, and the many other legal services providers.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Can you please join me in acknowledging all of them? I've been surrounded by people in my own office who are incredibly caring, hard working, and devoted. Curt Shibata, Jaye Atiburcio, Ginger Pana, and Grace Ginoza. Curt pulled an all nighter last night helping us get ready for for this, by the way.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    And the others are there pretty late too. Along with my outstanding law clerks and externs. And the judiciary and I have been blessed by an amazing administrative director, Rod Maile, as well as his deputies Daylin-Rose Heather, Brandon Kimura, and Iris Murayama, and Special Assistant Lisa Lum. Rod will be retiring later this year. For over 40 years, he's been a trusted and respected voice in state government.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    Can you please join me in recognizing? Most importantly, I want to thank my family for all their support and the countless sacrifices they made for me. My parents Connie and Bill, my children Andrew and Sarah and stepson Trevor, my brother in law Joe Mahoe, Alvin Akee, and especially my beloved wife, Dr. Gailynn Williamson, who unfortunately could not be here today. I mentioned at the start of my remarks that I didn't know anyone when I arrived in Hawaii. Fortunately for me, the first person I met when I walked off the plane was Gailynn. It was the best day of my life.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    I thank her from the bottom of my heart for the beautiful life we built together. In closing, as I look back at my time at the judiciary, I realize that the most powerful lessons I've learned are the simplest. Do what's right. Don't forget your roots. Speak up for people who don't have a voice. Treat everyone with respect.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    These are the values that guide what we do at the judiciary every day and will serve as a shining beacon for our future. The law shouldn't be an abstraction. It should always be about helping people find justice. It should be applied evenly to all, no matter if you're wealthy and powerful or on the outside looking in.

  • Mark Recktenwald

    Person

    It should be about ensuring voices are heard and that everyone will get a fair shake when they walk into one of our courtrooms. That's the promise of justice for all, and I'm proud to be part of an institution that works every day to make that promise a reality. Once again, thank you to the Legislature for all your support and for giving me this opportunity to speak with you today. Mahalo and aloha.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    Governor Green, Lieutenant Governor Luke, esteemed colleagues, and honored guests, it is my honor to give closing remarks today. I'd like to start by thanking the Senate for hosting this joint session today. Thank you, President Kouchi, for your kind remarks over the past few weeks, first on opening day, then at the governor's state of the state address.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    And you even complimented me during our Civil Beat Cafe panel yesterday. I know you buttering me up had nothing, absolutely nothing to do with our budget negotiations that concluded yesterday. Smooth, sly, smart, and subtle, these traits have served you well. And at the end of the day, your Senators and your Senate staff are the beneficiaries.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    Thank you to the justices, judges, and members of the judiciary for all that you do. It is wonderful to hear that the state of the judiciary is strong and thriving. Chief Justice Recktenwald, thank you most of all. Your leadership has been steady, thoughtful, and innovative.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    Your outstanding commitment to public service reminds me of another prominent Member of the Hawaii Supreme Court, Justice Edward Nakamura. Ed was my husband Galen's uncle, and the first person in my life to suggest that I should run for the House of Representatives over 30 years ago. For many years, Ed was a labor lawyer for the ILWU. He spent years at the Legislature advocating for Hawaii workers. Ed was instrumental in writing the 1974 Hawaii Prepaid Health Care Act, Workers Compensation Temporary Disability Laws. They were not easy accomplishments.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    Year after year, the bills died, but Ed, together with Senator Nadao Yoshinaga and Representative Yoshito Takamine, persevered and helped steer Hawaii towards having some of the most progressive worker protections and benefits in the nation. Later, he became a Hawaii Supreme Court justice and remained a strong advocate for the people of Hawaii.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    Ed's legacy is one we can all admire. And Ed would have been so proud of you, CJ. Like Ed, you understood the real life problems of people. You led the judiciary with humility and have always been an independent thinker. You have persevered and thought about so many, brought about so many positive changes for Hawaii, including the Truancy Court, Community Outreach Court, Women's Court, Environmental Court, Veterans Treatment Court, Access to Justice Centers, and the list goes on and on.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    But I'd like to give a special shout out for, during the pandemic, allowing us to all work on the eviction mediation program that helped the most vulnerable residents when they needed it the most. And on that note, I'd like to give a special shout out to Judge Melanie May, retired Judge Joseph Cardoza, Brandon Kimura, and Senator Hashimoto for their work in crafting a law saving many from eviction. Your legacy is of a more accessible, stable, collaborative, and innovative judiciary than ever before.

  • Nadine Nakamura

    Legislator

    You have inspired an entire generation of local attorneys. You will be dearly missed as our Chief Justice, but I am confident that you will continue serving our community in invaluable ways. There being no further business, I declare this joint session adjourned.

Currently Discussing

Bill Not Specified at this Time Code

Next bill discussion:   January 23, 2025

Previous bill discussion:   January 23, 2025

Speakers

State Agency Representative