Senate Standing Committee on Hawaiian Affairs
- Tim Richards
Legislator
Hello, everyone. This is going to be exceedingly short agenda. This is Committee on Hawaiian Affairs. We have one measure on the docket, GM574. That was a nomination that was reached with withdrawn. So we have nothing on our agenda. Meeting is AD.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Hello and welcome to the hearing with the Senate Committees on Economic Development and our good friend and Tourism and our good friends at Hawaiian affairs. Today's Tuesday, April 15th, 2025. This is our 1:10pm agenda and we're in Conference Room 2 to 5. This hearing is being streamed live on YouTube.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
In the unlikely event that we must abruptly end this hearing due to technical difficulties, another notice will be posted at a later date. The Committee has gone through all the testimony, so we encourage you to stand on your written testimony. And if you'd like to add comments, you will have one minute to do so.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
This agenda has one House Resolution, so we'll go ahead and get started with HCR192. First up, Director Tokioka in support. Next up, Pony Askew testifying for Office of Hawaiian Affairs in support, Steve Alm, prosecuting attorney. Hello.
- Steve Alm
Person
Good afternoon. Chairs, Vice Chairs, Members of the Committee, Honorable Prosecutor Steve Alm. We're in opposition to this. I certainly appreciate the intent. If anyone deserves a break, it's Native Alliance. I just don't think gambling is the right way. And there are. This working group is not going to look at pros and cons.
- Steve Alm
Person
It's going to be how do we get gambling here? And I'm really worried about that. The red flags coming from all over. And even John Oliver had a story about this and all the problems on the mainland. But research has found it's going to help the least advantageous.
- Steve Alm
Person
The poorest folks among us are going to get hurt the most by legalized gambling. And they're going to be the ones that are problem gamblers. And unfortunately, the business model for the state is going to be to make money off the problem gamblers.
- Steve Alm
Person
Two weeks ago, the mayor and City County of Baltimore filed a complaint for unfair and deceptive practices against FanDuels and DraftKings. 96% of the bettors online lose money. Only 4% make money. So they make. 96% of our Hawaii citizens are going to lose at sports gambling.
- Steve Alm
Person
I'm afraid it'll tarnish sports for us people at UH football games, wahine volleyball games. I mean, look at their phones betting on. Will they make the field goal? Will it be a pass next time and the like. And I hate to see that. So the Department of Taxation and I'll Finish up with this.
- Steve Alm
Person
The Department of Taxation testified in February that it's only going to bring in 5.5 million the first year, 5.5.3, 5.5 the second, 5.7 third out of a budget of 10 billion. With all the problems associated with this, I really don't think this is a good path to go. Thank you.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Thank you. Next up, Christine right in Aloha, Lava District Partners. Thank you. Next up, Cody Sula, Iron Worker Stabilization Fund. In support, Madeleine McKeague testifying for Consul Native Hawaiian Advancement.
- Madeline McCaig
Person
Hi, Aloha. Madeline McCaig. On behalf of the Council for Native Hawaiian Advancement, we stand on our testimony and strong support. I think. I would also like to emphasize the importance of making informed decisions. And I think that's a strong part of this working group. Gaming is a very diverse economic field.
- Madeline McCaig
Person
Just because sports gambling might have a variety of problems, that doesn't mean perhaps bingo doesn't. And I think the importance of making an informed decision, doing research into this is the most important part of this. And so that's why we encourage a strong support on this. Mahalo. Thank you.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Next up, Pompey Kanehele for testifying for Nation of Hawaii and support, Brendan Makaawa testifying for Hawaii Nation.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
Aloha. I'm in support of this bill and to respectfully request a seat at the table. Over the past four years, we visited Native nations across the US from the Seminoles in Florida to the Pechanga in California, learning directly from their experiences with gaming.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
What we've seen is that there is a good way to do this and a bad way. For us, this isn't about chasing profits. It's about reconciliation. It's about restoring self determination and creating a framework that helps uplift our people while also protecting them.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
We believe our lived experiences, our cultural grounding and the relationships we've built with other Native nations gives us a unique perspective. We're ready to contribute meaningfully to this working group to ensure that gaming in Hawaii, if it comes, will be done the right way. Mahalo.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Thank you. Next up, John Garcia, Nation of Hawaii. Also in support, Dwayne Bautista in support. Melkahele. In support. Sheila Medeiros in opposition. Roku Aina Letua in opposition. Johnny May L. Perry in opposition. And then Lebomi Khan, opposition. Michael Older in support. There four others also in opposition. Anybody else wishing to testify on this measure?
- Edward Roland
Person
Aloha, Ala. My name is Edward Roland, senior pastor of International Life Christian Center on the Wai Coast. I believe is the. I don't think it's a good idea to bring in gambling, in I'm come, I come directly from California. California. I am an American Indian and it didn't help us out.
- Edward Roland
Person
All it does is just bring more awareness of what is taking place. And it's everybody says about bringing in the revenue really doesn't because what happens is people that don't have money want to go to the casinos to see if they can make money. And that's where it all starts at. Before you know it, there ain't no.
- Edward Roland
Person
Homes, there ain't no families because it's. Been generated by the gambling that is taking place. I'm originally from there. Like I said, I am an American Indian. Right now my family is in the. Position of fighting to do something. But like I said, all it's going. To do is bring problem. I'm not, I'm against it. Thank you.
- Nelson Sua
Person
Hello. Hello. My name is Nelson Sua. I come from a family that's done over 230 years in prison time or prison time. We were labeled the brotherhood of crime. And. I've given my life to the Lord and because of that experience on that side of the fence.
- Nelson Sua
Person
But a lot of you guys might not be seeing is the onslaught of criminal activity and organizations that will come into the state outside of Hawaii. Right. And this is going to kill our descendants basically. And at the end of the day I don't care how much money that we need.
- Nelson Sua
Person
It doesn't justify the loss that we're going to have with our losing our kids to crime, to addiction, to suicide. And that's how the dark side works. It comes in with a little piece and then it starts to manifest. And there's already organizations that are here. So I just stand against that this bill.
- Christina Everett
Person
Aloha. I'm Christina Everett with Project Nehemiah, Hawaii. What this Bill will do, it's going to create a pipeline of addiction and broken families. Legalizing gambling leads to increased cases of addiction, especially the low income native and vulnerable populations. Families will be destroyed, marriages will be destroyed, homes will be lost and children will be neglected.
- Christina Everett
Person
This has been proven in states like Nevada, New Jersey. This is a backdoor to state run dependency program. FPASS HCR192 will justify new programs funded by the state to help gambling addicts. Programs that could have been avoided altogether.
- Christina Everett
Person
These programs will require millions of tax dollars while the state benefits from the very addiction it then prevents, pretends to solve. This cycle is manipulative and it's immoral. Crimes will increase. Theft and fraud to Fund gambling habits. This will come. Domestic violence will come. Illegal underground gambling will come. Children neglected will come.
- Christina Everett
Person
What you guys will promise with this bill? Economic growth from tourism. No growth of gambling Tourism, not local prosperity. This is not for the local people. Thank you.
- Angela Young
Person
Aloha, Angela Melody Young testifying on behalf of CARES wishing to comment.
- Angela Young
Person
So what's anticipated in this resolution can be more focused on balancing the positive economic development options for the Hawaiian community instead of the legalizing gambling and gaming because within the scope of the work it talks about economic development initiatives and not just exclusive of gambling and legalizing gaming.
- Angela Young
Person
So the small businesses that can be empowered in the Hawaiian community, for example food booths and food trucks and for the state to legislate parameters to provide commercial kitchen access for development of Hawaiian food trucks while promoting expansion of agricultural development to improve quality of agriculturally grown ingredients in Hawaiian fusion food can help with a creative skill set to develop creative talent in business skills for the Hawaiian community.
- Angela Young
Person
And then they can have Hawaii's finest. More food trucks. Right? And very monarch festivals.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Hello, Medeiros. I'm just going to read off my prepared statement. Oh. Legalized gambling is a short term pleasure for long term pain. I strongly oppose legalizing gambling in Hawaii. It's a reckless bet that promises quick cash for delivers long term devastation to our communities and future generations. The evidence is clear. Gambling fuels addiction across ethnic groups.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
A 2016 Pili Vaivai studies found 33.2% of Honolulu's Filipino Americans, 20% of Native Hawaiians and 25% of Japanese Americans gamble yearly. With the addiction rates rising. Pennsylvania saw a 10% surge in addiction hotline calls after legalizing casinos per a 2022 Civil Beat report. A trend that would grip Hawaii's diverse population. Crime spikes in gambling hubs.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Las Vegas has a 20% higher violent crime rate than non gambling cities per 2023 FBI data. And a 2025 Justice Department case tied Oahu's illegal game rooms to meth trafficking. Human trafficking flourishes in gambling zones. Nevada's legalized scene correlates with a 30% higher trafficking rate per a 2021 Polaris study. Endangering vulnerable Native Hawaiian, Filipino and Asian communities.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Family structures. 40% of gambling addicts face divorce per 2023 Hawaii Island Recovery Report. Leaving Keiki neglected and unstable. These broken homes create generational trauma with grandchildren facing Poverty, addiction, emotional scars. As studies shown, children of addicts are 50% more likely to develop substance abuse issues per 2021 National Institute on Drug Abuse report.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Bottom line, our mopunas are going to suffer. I'm a grandmother. I'm sure some of you are grandmothers, too. We can't allow this. Thank you.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Representing myself in International Bureau of Life Christian Center. And I strongly oppose this bill. And one of the reasons is I come out of addiction, and I've been an addict about over 30 years, since I was 14. Right now I'm 55. And, you know, I firsthand saw what gambling and addiction can do. Two families.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And not only that, you know, it creates a hub for criminal activity. And I've been involved in game rooms and gambling and drugs, so I know these things firsthand.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
And now that I'm on the other side, we've been battling game rooms and men and women who have come out of addiction in the Waianae area and within that whole west side from Waipahu to Macau.
- Unidentified Speaker
Person
Well, in conclusion, you know, you're only hurting the Hawaiian people because that's who lives here, you know, and if you continue to give a place where they can have a hub for these people to come in and start addictive behaviors, it's only going to get worse, you know, and if you've been an addict for many years, it's going to take many years to come out of that darkness.
- Stella Romo
Person
Hi, my name is Stella Romo from International River of Life Christian Center. I also oppose this because, like, I have grandchildren also, and I have grandchildren right now that don't have a father because of gambling. He got caught up in gambling.
- Stella Romo
Person
And after gambling, it goes to drugs, goes to alcohol, it goes to stealing, taking things that don't belong to him and to. To just keep going with that addiction. That's just another addiction. Because we get so caught up in doing these things that we want more. We want more. We think we're going to win.
- Stella Romo
Person
We think we're going to win, and we're not going to win. We're just. And what happens? We end up losing your. You end up losing your children, you end up losing your. Your job, your. Everything that you have worked so hard for. Now you don't have it. Now we're going to have innocent people in.
- Stella Romo
Person
In the society that, you know what, that are barely making it and thinking, Oh, it's going to be okay to try to go one day and just think that they're going to come up one day just like an addiction. That's how they are. They think they're going to come up one day, but they end up losing everything.
- Stella Romo
Person
So I. I strongly oppose to this because, you know, we see what's going to take place for our next generation. Generation. Our children are going to suffer and. Our children's children are going to suffer.
- Wendell Hirschman
Person
Wendell Hirschman. Thank you. I don't think we should have the gambling in Hawaii because it's gonna cause a lot of chaos. You know, you're gonna have, like, family.
- Wendell Hirschman
Person
It's gonna get, you know, like, let's say for an example, if these gambling starts and then people begin to get addicted to the gambling and they want to borrow money so they can gamble even more, and then they cannot pay back to the person that they got the money from. Okay.
- Wendell Hirschman
Person
You know, they can get killed if they don't pay back the money. And then we're going to have all these criminals, like syndicates, the cartels, and all these people getting involved. And I don't think we should have it here. Hawaii is not a place for it. Maybe in Vegas, but not in Hawaii. This is a paradise.
- Wendell Hirschman
Person
We don't have enough room for this kind of stuff. Okay. And I oppose the bill.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Thank you. Anybody else wishing to testify in this measure, see non Members. Any questions?
- Tim Richards
Legislator
Hello, Brendan. Thank you. Question. You've heard the other side, right? Could you respond, please?
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
Well, you know, I'm not in favor of gaming per se, just for economic growth. I think there's a bunch of different things we can do. But, you know, if we are heading down that road, I believe that Hawaiians should be involved because we will be impacted the most.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
I think that there, you know, through our studies, through going around the country, we met with the Muskogee in Oklahoma. We met with the Seminoles in Florida, Pechanga in California. A bunch of different tribes. There are good ways to do this where we are protected, but Hawaiians have to be leading these conversations and not the operators.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
It's not fail proof. I mean, there are going to be problems. But like what Prosecutor Alm stated, we cannot have these companies come in just strictly looking for profit. If we go in that route, we're gonna make big mistakes. I think our Hawaiian communities need to be leading these discussions.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
That's why I appreciate the changes in the bills to remove the operators by name. I think we can adopt some of the measures that the Native nations have used to help mitigate these issues, but they're not. You know, it's not perfect.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
You know, gaming has its flaws, but there's a good way we can do this and then there's a bad way.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Hang on. You know, I've heard the test of fires talk about gaming. Right. You realize this is a working group that they're convening to understand.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
Yeah. And that's why, you know, we want to be part of the discussion. You know, in other instances, we've been against the gaming because, you know, and we still are against, like, online gaming and all these things because it's, again, it's not led by us. It's led by operators who want to come in and make a profit.
- Brendan Makaawa
Person
And the state is not going to make as much money as they think it is if they let these guys come in and dictate how we make the money.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Yes. So as the RESO stance, it's to convene a tourism and gaming working group. Right. That has a certain amount of people, including social services, law enforcement, taxation. It also allows for the culture persons also to add on names as they see fit. Yes. You understand that? Okay, thank you.
- Madeline McCaig
Person
Yeah, absolutely. I think, first of all, I want to mahalo the Lohui who has showed up today. I think it's incredibly important to hear those stories, and I am incredibly receptive to them. And that's why I wanted to stress my oral testimony, the importance of making an informed decision.
- Madeline McCaig
Person
I think I understand and support a working group led by Hawaiians to explore this. That's not the same as legalizing it. That's not the same as a commitment.
- Madeline McCaig
Person
But I want to understand what we're doing because I think I really do feel that there is a right way to do it, but then a thousand wrong ways to do it.
- Madeline McCaig
Person
And so being able to have the right people at the table to talk that through, to go through the risks and to try to mitigate that as much as possible, or even just to decide it's not worth it for us, I think that's an important step to just start the conversation.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Any other questions? Oh, sorry, we're not taking testimony. Okay. No, no. You. You guys asked the questions. We asked the question. Any other questions?
- Tim Richards
Legislator
Prosecutor. And I appreciate this conversation because I'm listening very, very carefully to all of you. And Chair DeCoite has pointed out this is a working group to explore. This isn't to validate whether or not gaming is the right thing to do. That being said, because part of it is gaming is part of the exploration.
- Tim Richards
Legislator
It's not the whole exploration. So I just wanted to state that up front that I'm not convinced this is the right thing to do, but I also don't have enough data to know. So, Prosecutor, just comments again from the conversation, please.
- Steve Alm
Person
Yeah, well, for certain things, the online game is happening so fast around the country because it was 2018 that the US Supreme Court said other states can do it besides Vegas. So 38 states have rushed into this. And that's the one that scares me the most because that's a casino in your hand.
- Steve Alm
Person
So in the privacy of their living room, young men especially are going to go nuts with this and the game. You know, I share Mr. Concerns about the Fanduels and the DraftKings because they're going to be encouraging you to bet. And they say we have legacy bets.
- Steve Alm
Person
Well, legacy bets, you know, legacy honors, that means you've lost $10,000 or you've lost $20,000, you're a loser. I mean, the management company operation at the University of California, San Diego looked at it and like I said before, 96% of the bettors lose online, 4% win.
- Steve Alm
Person
And if they keep winning, they cut them off or limit them to dollar bets because you don't have the right to gamble. So I'm just worried that it could tarnish sports. I mean, if you have a casino, you have one place to go. You've got to get maybe dressed up, I don't know.
- Steve Alm
Person
But if you act nuts, they'll throw you out. But it takes an effort as opposed to being in the living room. And I appreciate that it's this working group, but the working group is working toward finding ways to legalize gambling.
- Steve Alm
Person
The way I read the hcr, it's not like asking them to do a cost benefit analysis like you might ask LRB to do it. And the fact that I'm glad you took those names out, but that's to me, the intention. And they're going to want to get involved in this.
- Steve Alm
Person
So we've seen increases in domestic violence and other stuff. The native Hawaiians have been screwed here forever. So whatever can be done to help them. I totally agree with that. I just think we're going to end up with a new generation of problem gamblers, especially with sports bookmaking that's the one that scares me the most.
- Samantha DeCorte
Legislator
Thank you, Prosecutor. Do you see this eventually working at some point? I mean, it's so hard to predict. What'S going to be happening five or 10 years down the road. I do believe that there is kind. Of a niche here, however, as example.
- Samantha DeCorte
Legislator
For the district I represent, you know, I mean, we're understaffed as far as HPD officers, Sheriffs are under. So I understand the crime element of it, that my community is like, they're on high alert with this thing. Right. So I understand that. Do you see a way that there can be a discussion?
- Samantha DeCorte
Legislator
I mean, is it, is it the crime factor? Is it, you know, what exactly is it working in other states where they do have full capacity of HPD officers?
- Steve Alm
Person
I don't think the crime part is the biggest problem. I think it's the personal bankruptcies, it's the personal credit getting overextended, it's the credit cards going nuts, not paying your car. I think that's the more likely option. There will be some loan sharking that, you know, we see in other states where people borrow money to gamble.
- Steve Alm
Person
And I see that as being a problem. But the, the problem is it's, it's the activity itself that is so addicting. And that's why I keep bringing up sports online bookmaking, because it is, apparently it is the most addictive form of gambling. And I think it's because you can do it 247 in your house.
- Steve Alm
Person
And I've read about professional gamblers who will set their thing to make a bet at 2 o' clock in the morning to try to fool those other firms from thinking that, Oh, they're so addicted, they're going to bet at 2:00 in the morning. They just want some of the deals that you get at the beginning.
- Steve Alm
Person
So if you start losing money, they're going to say, Oh, Steve, here's $500 to get you rolling again. Well, and I'll bet the $500 then. I'll bet more than that. It's just the activity is so addicting. And I think it's the sports bookmaking, because it could be 247 that, that scares me the most.
- Samantha DeCorte
Legislator
Yeah, and I appreciate those comments because, I mean, you're preaching to the choir here, considering the amount of game rooms. Chicken fights we have going on in. Our community and all those kinds of things. But I really appreciate your feedback. Thank you. Prosecuting attorney and chairs. Thank you very much.
- Steve Alm
Person
And because the lowest income folks get hurt, the Most that's native Hawaiians. So I.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Any other questions? I want to do a follow up. So. You know, I think. Yeah. Notice that this also has a report that comes back to the Legislature. While there's 50 something different people that sit on there, it is within the chairpersons to also add on additional people.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
But wouldn't you want to know whether we can peel this fire on the report coming back that this is a bad way to go versus just jumping to the gun? I would love to see the data. I think as a prosecuting attorney, wouldn't you want to have all your evidence prior to making that decision?
- Steve Alm
Person
Absolutely. So I'd much prefer any sort of study or working group rather than passing like sports bookmaking.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So this is a working group that will come back with a report which I think would be really helpful for us to then say, based on those individuals that sit on this working group, that they can come back to this body and say, you know what, this is a really bad idea.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
The data shows us that this will continue to be addictive, the social service will diminish. Because, you know, I have my own concerns, but I kind of want to know so I can make my own informed decision as well as I would expect this Committee to do versus us kind of just, you know, firing off without.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
I mean, I've always looked towards you to take on information and then decide what the information.
- Steve Alm
Person
As long as the working group is open to hearing that kind of data. Because the way I read the resolution, I'm worried that it's. It's just how can we open up? How can we do casinos, how can we do lotteries, how can we do sportsbooking as opposed to the question of.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
But I think because you have a seat for law enforcement here and law enforcement has been doing a lot of busting on these games, I think it would be super helpful for us to know those amount of things occurring, I think would help us make a better and more informed decision versus of just saying, ah, you know, let's just blow it off.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
I think we'll have more credibility to then say, I don't think this works for the State of Hawaii.
- Steve Alm
Person
I agree. We've been working with Michael Ambert on busting all those 60 game rooms.
- Steve Alm
Person
He's willing to take on any activity and we're happy. I just hope the. The personal side of it, the bankruptcy side, the other states is part of it so they can make an informed decision. I agree with you completely.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
And I think it'll allow us to add on. Okay, that'd be great. I'd be happy to participate. I would love to have you on there as well. Thank you. Thank you.
- Tim Richards
Legislator
Yeah. So. No, no, no. Thank you. And Brendan, definitely hearing what you are saying about a seat at the table literally on this situation because I agree you guys need to have seat at the table. But like I said, I'm not convinced that this is the right direction for gaming. But I want to know.
- Tim Richards
Legislator
So Chair, no ready for decision making? I think we're ready for a decision.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Yeah. Okay. So HCR 192 requesting the Department of Business Economic Development Tourism to establish a Native Hawaiian working Native Hawaiian Economic Development Working Group recommendation. I believe based on the testimony and the fact that we need more information to make a sound decision going forward. I agree with all of you folks.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
As a Native Hawaiian myself, addiction, social services, all of these things lack what is there. I don't believe even in the realm of gaming in Hawaii that revenue stream is there to address many of these things.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
I believe that HCR192HD2 has narrowed the scope of this working group and is literally contrary to the intent of the original resolution. So I'm recommending that we pass this resolution by amending it to incorporate the version that was passed by the Senate in SCR121SD1. That will also allow us to add on individuals to this working group.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
That will help us make a better and more informed decision. The Senate version would help us in considering a legalized gaming framework for the state. And what direction? Whether it will take a framework in legalizing gaming or say we've had enough of this conversation and put it to rest in the future regarding gaming legislation.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
With that being said, that is the recommendation. Recess any discussion.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
So again, recommendation is to pass without the scope of this working group and it's contrary to the intent of the original resolution.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Recommend that we pass this resolution by many to incorporate the version that was passed by the Senate STR121 SD1 Senate version will help us in considering a legalized gaming framework for the State of whether or not that direction is the right direction we take in the future regarding gaming legislation. Any discussion?
- Tim Richards
Legislator
Chair, let me make a comment. Go ahead, people in the room. You can end online. Obviously this is a very sensitive subject and don't think that your Senators up here are taking this lightly because they're not. We're looking at many different facets that we're going through and every statement made by every person was listened to very carefully.
- Tim Richards
Legislator
On the group though I trust my colleagues, we don't always agree, which is why this is a very effective way passing legislation. So I think we're ready for the vote.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
You know, and likewise, you know, I think all of us have considered testimony and as we look towards people testifying, we also understand where everybody is coming from and the right and wanting to know. So with that being said, let's take the vote. Mr. Chair for the vote. Chair goes Aye. I vote yes.
- Tim Richards
Legislator
Okay. On the subject of HCR192, its chair is recommended pass but I'm voting with reservations.
- Joy San Buenaventura
Legislator
Okay, voting on HCR192 HD2 Chair's recommendation is to pass with amendments. [Roll Call] Chair recommendation did not pass.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
With that, this meeting is adjourned. Aloha and welcome to the hearing with Senate Committee on Economic Development and Tourism. Today is Tuesday, April 15th, 2025 and this is our 1:15pm agenda and we are in Conference Room 225. This agenda has one House Resolution, so we'll go ahead with HCR 77.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
First up on the testifiers is Wendy Gady from Agri Development Corporation.
- Cedric Gates
Person
Hello, Aloha. Chair, members of the committee, Cedric Gates here on behalf of the Department of Agriculture. The Department stands on its written testimony offering comments supporting the intent and deferring to ADC. Thank you.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Okay, next up, HCR 77, Larry Jeffs in support, Brian Miyamoto testifying for Hawaii Farm Bureau, in support, Stephanie Whelan, Cuneifillage Holding Corporation on Zoom. Go ahead, Stephanie.
- Stephanie Whalen
Person
Okay. Thank you, Senator, for hearing this- this measure and I hope you have my written testimony. I'm sorry it was late, but what I wanted to do is that to indicate how important I believe this is to the agriculture industry as a whole.
- Stephanie Whalen
Person
And the legislature has been very helpful in providing many laws and things to help and support agriculture. But somehow we're still struggling to get it going and be effective. And I think part of the problem is because we have a little bit of land here under I.
- Stephanie Whalen
Person
We fix a water system over there, we put a hub here, and these things are all scattered. And here's an opportunity just by chance that many of the things agriculture needs is all in one place. It doesn't have to only be here.
- Stephanie Whalen
Person
It can be found on each one of the islands if this concept proves to be successful. And basically, in this Corridor from the H1 freeway all the way to Waialua, it has small, large and medium farmers. Many. Much of the land has already been put into IAL plus, or conservation easement, which keeps it in ag forever.
- Stephanie Whalen
Person
It has actually four water systems, it has two ditch systems, and it has two wastewater treatment systems. That gives it sustainability.
- Stephanie Whalen
Person
Yes. I'm just saying that all these elements that agriculture needs to be a successful industry are present. Thank you. Thank you.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Next up, Donna Busimi in support. Anybody else wishing to testify? Okay. Yeah. Can you be. I'll lose quorum shortly and this bill will- this reso will die.
- Angela Young
Person
Okay. I just wanted to be helpful to this discussion. Although it's not my community, I'm testifying in strong support. Okay. Can I just. Yeah. Come.
- Angela Young
Person
Okay. So what this resolution contemplates in terms of projected development in the agriculture industry and future investments in farm products is that there will be advancement in agriculture as a strong economic development sector. Right.
- Angela Young
Person
So new infrastructure and planning for it involves the county's offices of Department of Environmental Services, Board of Water Supply and Planning for electrical utilities. This is a supporting foundation of preparing for growth in ag development and farm.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Thank you. Okay. Okay. Anybody else wishing to testify? Seeing none. Members, we're going straight to decision making. Okay.
- Lynn DeCoite
Legislator
Recommendation is to pass it an SD one that would request that the ADC establish a list of prioritizing potential infrastructure improvement projects not in just the central Oahu agriculture corridor, but also on a statewide basis because this may benefit many other agricultural areas in the state. Any discussion? Seeing none. Vice chair for the vote. Chair goes aye.
- Committee Secretary
Person
Chair votes aye on HCR 77. [roll call]. Three members present. Recommendations adopted.
Bill Not Specified at this Time Code
Next bill discussion: April 15, 2025
Previous bill discussion: April 15, 2025
Speakers
Legislator